First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
Challenges to library books rise in 2004

By The Associated Press

NEW YORK — Attempts to have library books removed from shelves increased by more than 20% in 2004 over the previous year, according to a new survey by the American Library Association.

Maya Angelou’s I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings, frequently targeted in previous years for a rape scene and for being perceived by some as “anti-white,” was among the works most criticized last year.

“It all stems from a fearfulness of well-meaning people,” says Michael Gorman, president of the library association. “We believe in parental responsibility, and that you should take care of what your children are reading. But it’s not your responsibility to tell a whole class of kids what they should read.”

The number of books challenged last year jumped to 547, compared to 458 in 2003, with the library association estimating four to five unreported cases for each one documented. According to the ALA, a challenge is “a formal, written complaint, filed with a library or school requesting that materials be removed because of content or appropriateness.”

National organizations such as the American Family Association have been involved with library challenges, but far more complaints come from individual parents and patrons, according to the ALA.

The ALA study was to be released today in anticipation of the 24th annual Banned Books Week, which runs Sept. 24 to Oct. 1 and is co-sponsored by the ALA, the American Booksellers Association and others. Gorman acknowledged that few books are actually banned, adding that Banned Books Week is a “catchy name.”

Robert Cormier’s classic The Chocolate War topped the 2004 list of challenged books, cited for sexual content, violence and language. It was followed by Walter Myers’ Fallen Angels, a young adult novel set in Harlem and Vietnam and criticized for racism, language and violence.

No. 3, Michael Bellesiles’ Arming America, has been widely disputed, even by its original publisher. First released in 2000, the book challenges the idea that the United States has always been a gun-oriented culture and was awarded the Bancroft Prize for history. But questions about Bellesiles’ scholarship led publisher Alfred A. Knopf to drop the book and Bancroft officials to withdraw the prize.

“If you’re a freedom-to-read person, pulling a book like that one is not that different from any book that might have fake scholarship,” Gorman says. “No matter how wrong a book might be, people should have access to it. It’s a slippery slope once you start removing books like that.”

Also high on the ALA list were Angelou’s memoir and two books with gay content, The Perks of Being a Wallflower by Stephen Chbosky, and King & King, by Linda de Haan and Stern Nijland.

The numbers for 2004 were the highest since 2000, but still well below the peak from a decade ago, when more than 700 books were challenged.

“A lot of people were worried that challenges would go up under President Bush, but the highest numbers were during the Clinton administration,” Gorman says. “I think that came from resentment among conservatives that Bill Clinton was president. You had the whole thing about gays in the military. You had people who believed that somehow Clinton was not a legitimate president.”

Gorman said the majority of challenges happen at school libraries, although a recent incident involved the general public branches in Denver. Prompted by complaints of pornographic and violent content, the Denver system canceled its subscription to four Spanish-language adult comic books.

“It’s a perpetual problem, and it attacks fundamental American liberties — the attempt to impose one’s own positions on society as a whole,” Gorman says.


From Harry Potter to 'Blubber': 100 books make list of most challenged of the '90s

Authors, free-speech advocates say parents don't have right to make book decisions for children of others. 07.20.00

Pennsylvania school board strikes novel from curriculum
Muhlenberg officials cite Buffalo Tree's explicit sexual references, vulgar language, also remove book from school library, classroom shelves. 04.18.05

Wash. school district bans novel about gay teens
Superintendent says risky behavior of meeting people via Internet — not homosexual theme — is reason for her objection to book. 11.22.05

Celebrating the right to read
By Melanie Bengtson ALA kicks off its 25th Annual Banned Books Week, honoring works that have been challenged, questioned, burned or banned. 09.25.06

Number of books facing challenge drops to all-time low
ALA official says two reasons may be that librarians are better prepared to defend books, would-be censors are focusing efforts online. 09.29.06

Banned books
Book censorship

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Friday, July 25, 2008 | 02:41:13
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links