First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
Religion and politics Q&A

By The Associated Press
10.18.04

This election year has seen unprecedented outreach to churches by the Republican and Democratic presidential campaigns, and intensified political activity by the religious groups themselves. But some watchdogs for separation of church and state are concerned that congregations are violating the federal tax code, which restricts the political activities of certain nonprofits, including churches.

Here are some questions and answers about what houses of worship can and can’t do in the political arena:

Q: Why are there restrictions on churches and politics?

A: In 1954, the Internal Revenue Code was amended to prevent tax-exempt groups from campaigning on behalf of, or against, candidates. Churches are in this category. Lyndon B. Johnson, then a senator, introduced the change.

Q: What kind of activities are allowed under the federal code?

A: Churches can engage in a wide range of political activities, as long as the outreach does not involve campaigning for, or raising money for, a political party or candidate. They can distribute voter guides, run voter-registration drives, hold forums on public policy and invite politicians to speak to their congregations. However, they cannot endorse a candidate, and their political activity cannot be biased for or against a candidate, directly or indirectly.

Q: What constitutes a violation of these rules?

A: Churches would be in violation, for example, if they did not give equal speaking opportunities to political candidates for the same office, if they distributed voter guides that described a candidate’s position in a biased way, or if they indicated support for a candidate they had invited as a speaker. While church-state separation watchdogs often complain of inherent bias in faith-based voter guides or registration drives, it is ultimately up to the IRS to decide whether it rises to the level of a code violation.

Q: Do the restrictions apply to clergy as well?

A: No. As long as religious leaders make it clear that they are speaking on their own behalf and not representing their church, they can volunteer for campaigns and endorse a candidate. For example, James Dobson, head of the Christian nonprofit Focus on the Family, has said he will vote for President Bush, but took pains to make it clear his organization was not making an endorsement.

Q: What happens if a church violates the restrictions?

A: The IRS can revoke the church’s tax-exempt status for a period of time or can impose a tax on its political expenditures. However, the IRS rarely takes these actions. Melissa Rogers, a church-state expert and visiting professor at Wake Forest University Divinity School, said the IRS cautiously enforces the rules because it doesn’t want to be viewed as abusing its authority over religious groups.

Q: Who monitors the churches?

A: Anyone can file a complaint with the IRS, which decides whether to begin a formal inquiry. Americans United for Separation of Church and State, the Washington watchdog group, says it has filed just eight complaints with the IRS this year. Often, there is no direct evidence of bias, such as an improper endorsement, that meets the IRS standard for violations, Americans United says.

Q: Do religious groups support these restrictions?

A: Religious leaders differ on whether the rules are needed. Some are happy to keep partisan politics out of their congregations, while others feel the prohibitions squelch free speech. The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, a public-interest law firm, says warnings from the IRS and church-state watchdogs have unfairly intimidated clergy, giving the impression that pastors can be punished for preaching their religious beliefs from the pulpit.

Sources: IRS, Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life (See Pew Forum guide, “Politics and the Pulpit”)


Related

Group asks IRS to revoke Catholic diocese's tax exemption

Americans United says Colorado bishop crossed the line by saying Catholics should not receive Communion if they vote for politicians who disagree with church teachings. 05.28.04

Bush campaign's appeal to churches causes stir
Critics say e-mail urging parishioners to organize 'Friendly Congregations' could cost churches their tax breaks. 06.03.04

Congress mulls easing penalties for mixing religion, politics
Americans United head says he doesn't think it's coincidence measure was introduced same week Bush campaign targeted 1,600 congregations to recruit voters. 06.08.04

Watchdog group monitors politics in the pulpit
Meanwhile, Americans United files complaint with the IRS over Jerry Falwell column endorsing President Bush. 07.20.04

FEC clears Falwell on electioneering complaint
Agency says as founder of various media, Falwell had right to urge Bush’s re-election; potentially more damaging IRS complaint remains, however. 07.19.05

Ministers say they didn't endorse Obama
Hillary Clinton ran into some of the same questions after her campaign released its list of endorsements from black ministers late last month. 12.28.07

Calif. pastor's Huckabee endorsement draws IRS probe
Wiley Drake, who wrote press release on church stationery endorsing GOP presidential hopeful, says he has received 14-page letter announcing agency's investigation. 02.14.08

IRS investigating denomination over Obama speech
'When the invitation to an elected public official to speak to the national meeting of his own church family is called into question, it has a chilling effect on every religious community,' says United Church of Christ president. 02.27.08

Minn. minister tests prohibition on political preaching
Church-state separation group asked for IRS probe after Rev. Gus Booth alerted group to sermon he gave last month urging followers to oppose Barack Obama and Hillary Rodham Clinton. 06.14.08

Politics from the pulpit: free speech or partisan danger?
By Charles C. Haynes American churches getting conflicting advice about what constitutes impermissible political preaching. 10.03.04

Christian-Republican alliance: Faustian bargain?
By Charles C. Haynes When religion, politics mix too thoroughly, religion may find itself compromised. 11.21.04

IRS to churches: Watch what you preach
By Charles C. Haynes Conflicts over churches' political role have heated up again for this election cycle. 10.01.06

Tax exemptions

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print


Last system update: Friday, July 25, 2008 | 00:52:47
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

First Reports
Supreme Court
Experts
Columnists
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Sings™
Events
First Amendment
Schools

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links