First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
Publisher sues over removal from Ala. City Council meeting

By The Associated Press

HANCEVILLE, Ala. — A newspaper publisher who claims he was forcibly removed when he tried to ask a question at a City Council meeting has filed suit against Hanceville over the removal.

The suit filed in federal court on behalf of Edmund Flaig said a police officer removed him from a meeting on March 1, 2005, after he asked a question, which the public is not allowed to do during regular meetings.

The suit by Flaig, editor and publisher of The Trinity News, alleges slander, intentional infliction of emotional distress, interference with business relationships and a violation of his First Amendment rights.

“It’s a simple case,” Flaig’s attorney, William J. Freeman, said in a phone interview with The Cullman Times, which reported on the suit on Feb. 15. “It all comes down to the rights of the press to public information.”

In response to Flaig’s suit, the council went into executive session for 10 minutes during its Feb. 13 meeting, citing impending litigation, the Times reported. Upon returning, Councilman Hubert Jones made a motion for city attorney Edward Coey to file a countersuit. That countersuit is apparently to be filed against Flaig.

Flaig told the Cullman paper in a previous story that he spoke up in the March 1 meeting just to clarify if the council was selling one garbage truck or two.

“The officer grabbed me under my left arm and pulled me off my chair and tells me I’m going to jail,” he said. Flaig was not arrested.

Hanceville Police Officer Christopher Pearce said complaints had been made that Flaig’s “loud comments and talking during the meetings caused others to be unable to hear the meeting.” He said he was instructed not to let the March 1 meeting be disrupted. Police Chief Craig Richie has said Pearce used “appropriate” force after he “asked Flaig to quiet down nine times during the meeting.”

Under an ordinance passed Oct. 4, 2004, public comment is allowed during council work sessions but not regular meetings.


Federal judge halts Michigan city's effort to muzzle criticism

Court issues preliminary injunction barring Battle Creek officials from censoring public comment at open meetings. 07.16.99

Judge slaps Alabama city council critic with $150 fine for obstructing meeting
Defense attorney says 75-year-old is 'not in the habit of rolling over,' and will appeal municipal court decision. 08.23.99

Council president orders speaker's removal from meeting
ACLU says Danny Wells violated First Amendment when he told Burton, Mich., police to eject Laurie Tinnin for accusing officials of taking bribes. 01.21.05

Ala. woman arrested after council meeting wins damages
Dispute over water fees led to charges of harassment against Sharon Myers, but jurors found her First Amendment rights to speech, assembly were violated. 07.28.06

Miss. TV station objects to cameraman's ejection from meeting
Water board official has WDAM's Eddie Robertson escorted from meeting after he films member expressing displeasure with board of directors. 04.05.07

Speaking at public meetings

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Thursday, August 21, 2008 | 17:12:47
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links