First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
8th Circuit upholds dismissal of graduation-prayer lawsuit

By The Associated Press
08.21.03

LINCOLN, Neb. — A lawsuit filed against the Norfolk Public Schools and a school board member who led students in the Lord’s Prayer at a graduation ceremony was properly dismissed, a federal appeals court ruled.

The 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals yesterday upheld an earlier ruling by U.S. District Judge Laurie Smith Camp of Omaha.

The American Civil Liberties Union had filed the lawsuit on behalf of a Norfolk family, identified in court papers only as “John Doe, et al.”

The district and board member Jim Scheer were accused of violating the constitutionally implied separation of church and state.

Camp said she found no evidence that school officials knew what Scheer would say before the 2000 ceremony.

Norfolk School Board members traditionally have been allowed to speak at commencement ceremonies if they have a son or daughter graduating. Scheer was allowed to speak because his son was graduating.

In yesterday’s ruling, Judge Andrew Bogue wrote: “While no representative of the School District interrupted Scheer or disclaimed the recitation, there is no evidence that any School District officials knew about Scheer’s intentions prior to his speech.”

The ruling went on to say: “We believe that the informal policy which allowed Scheer to address the audience, the facts surrounding his speech, and the contents of the speech itself indicate sufficient separation between Scheer and his membership on the School Board to warrant a determination that his remarks were private and were not made in his representative capacity as an official of the School District.”

Tim Butz, executive director of the ACLU in Nebraska, declined to comment on the ruling. However, Butz said the ACLU would decide later whether to ask the court to reconsider its ruling.

The ACLU had contacted the school before the ceremony and warned officials that a planned prayer violated the Constitution.

Scheer’s prayer came not long after the school board decided to end the tradition of student-led prayer at graduation because a complaint had been filed with the school district.

The school announced that the scheduled prayer had been removed from the program. Scheer was allowed to speak, however, and led the students in prayer.

In a dissenting opinion, Judge Morris Arnold said Scheer used a “quite transparent effort to use his public office to thwart the efforts of the anonymous plaintiffs to ensure that the Constitution is observed.”

“In my view, in the context in which Mr. Scheer was operating, it is apparent that an objective observer could see his actions as state-sponsored,” he said. “Scheer was not merely speaking, he was praying. He invoked the deity. He ‘spoke’ in the vocative case and he invited others to join in. He recited a prayer that must have been familiar to everyone who was present. This was a religious act, pure and simple, at a state-sponsored event.”

Norfolk High School’s 2001 valedictorian led students in prayer at graduation. She received a standing ovation from her classmates.

The ACLU said it took no action in that case because the girl was not a school or government official and acted on her own.

In a similar case in 2001, Boone Central Schools Superintendent Richard Stephens was reprimanded by the state Department of Education for leading students in prayer.

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 2000 in Santa Fe Independent School District v. Doe, that public schools could not permit student-led prayers over district-owned public-address systems at athletic events. Such prayers, the high court said, give the appearance of school endorsement of religion.

The court’s sweeping language in the ruling was interpreted by some to extend far beyond school sports events — eventually affecting graduation ceremonies, moments of silence and more.

In its 1992 decision Lee v. Weisman, the high court barred clergy-led prayers — invocations and benedictions — at public school graduation ceremonies.


Previous
8th Circuit hears case of school official who led graduation prayer
Nebraska family says school board member's recitation of Lord's Prayer at 2000 ceremony violated the separation of church and state. 06.10.03

Related

Indiana high school drops graduation prayer

ICLU had threatened to sue if Avon officials included invocation in upcoming ceremony. 05.26.04

Arkansas House approves school-prayer bill
ACLU attorney warns bill is probably unconstitutional under U.S. Supreme Court rulings. 04.11.05

Graduation ceremonies
School prayer

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print


Last system update: Thursday, August 21, 2008 | 17:25:41
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

First Reports
Supreme Court
Experts
Columnists
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Sings™
Events
First Amendment
Schools

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links