First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
Bush administration opposes journalist shield law

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON — The No. 2 official at the Justice Department said yesterday that a shield law for reporters would encourage leaks of classified information.

At a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing, Deputy Attorney General Paul McNulty also said the proposal to protect reporters from having to identify their sources would “significantly weaken” the department’s ability to obtain information it needs to protect national security.

Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Arlen Specter, R-Pa., rejected McNulty’s opposition, saying he wants to push forward with the bill, S. 2831, which was inspired in part by last year’s jailing of journalist Judith Miller, then of The New York Times.

Miller had refused to cooperate with prosecutors in the Valerie Plame leak investigation. She subsequently disclosed that the source who told her of Plame’s CIA identity had been Vice President Dick Cheney’s now-indicted former chief of staff, I. Lewis Libby.

The Senate proposal would allow reporters to protect their confidential sources only in some instances. There would be exemptions in cases involving guilt or innocence, death or bodily harm, eyewitness accounts of criminal activity, and unauthorized disclosure of properly classified information.

McNulty said an exemption for national security was inadequate because the government would have to prove in court that a news leak harmed security. The Senate legislation would inject the federal judiciary “to an extraordinary degree” into executive branch functions, said McNulty.

A former solicitor general in the Bush administration, Theodore Olson, supported a shield law, saying it would promote investigative journalism.

“Naturally, the Department of Justice does not want its judgments second-guessed by courts,” Olson testified. But Congress should not recoil from ensuring judicial oversight on government decisions such as warrants for eavesdropping on phone conversations, Olson said.

Clarity also is needed given a split in the federal courts as to whether journalists are entitled to protections, Olson added.

In an interview, Lucy Dalglish, executive director of the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, said it was frustrating listening to testimony about “false, overwrought warnings about national security.”

The 109th Congress is running out of time to act on the legislation. A House version of the bill would allow courts to compel reporters’ testimony when necessary to prevent “imminent and actual harm” to national security. Differences between the two bills would have to be reconciled in a conference committee after the two chambers pass the bill.

Lawmakers make new bid to pass federal shield law
Anticipating objections from White House, sponsors have included exceptions that would apply if judge determines interest in disclosing source outweighs interest in newsgathering. 05.03.07

Sponsors hold out hope for federal press shield law
Indiana Republicans acknowledge limited time left for congressional approval this session, more compromises may be necessary. 07.26.06


Government won't seek to jail Chronicle reporters during appeal

Lance Williams and Mark Fainaru-Wada work out deal that while they fight federal judge's order to reveal sources for BALCO stories, authorities won't pursue sanctions. 09.06.06

9th Circuit: Freelancer must return to jail
Attorney for video journalist says Joshua Wolf will turn himself in before tomorrow's deadline, continue to appeal. 09.19.06

2 Chronicle reporters ordered to jail
Ruling stayed pending appeal to 9th Circuit; Lance Williams, Mark Fainaru-Wada say they won't reveal source in BALCO grand jury leak. 09.22.06

Bush declassifies part of intel report
President criticizes press, leakers concerning publicized portions of classified intelligence assessment suggesting Iraq war worsened terrorism. 09.26.06

News media seek documents in CIA leak case
Organizations argue that prosecutor didn't need testimony of reporters who were threatened with jail time because he knew source of leak all along. 12.26.06

House uses Sunshine to focus on open-government bills
Measures to protect whistleblowers, ease FOI requests, open presidential records may get votes; shield law effort unlikely to move to floor. 03.13.07

At ASNE, Specter advocates passage of shield law
Pennsylvania senator says journalists do more to shed light on corruption and mismanagement 'than all congressional oversight combined,' but fear of being jailed can hinder their work. 03.28.07

Shield law or no, protection of confidential sources uncertain
Proposed measures would offer only modest shelter for journalists who want to withhold identities of those who gave them information. 03.17.08

Ongoing confidential-sources cases
By Bill Kenworthy Compilation tracking current cases involving efforts to force journalists to disclose confidential sources. 08.04.05

Jailed & subpoenaed journalists — a historical timeline

Shield laws

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Wednesday, August 20, 2008 | 22:59:11
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links