First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
Music firm objects to anti-gay church's video parody

By The Associated Press
05.20.07

TOPEKA, Kan. — A church known nationally for picketing soldiers’ funerals is being accused by a music company of violating copyright laws with an Internet video parody of the 1980s song, “We Are the World.”

But an attorney for Westboro Baptist Church said May 17 that the parody, “God Hates the World,” is protected under First Amendment guarantees of freedom of speech and religious expression. She said the church intends to keep the video posted on its Web site.

It’s the latest incident bringing attention to Westboro Baptist and its pastor, the Rev. Fred Phelps Sr., and their ongoing campaign against homosexuality. On its Web site, Fox News described the song parody as a “new outrage.”

The church argues that soldiers’ deaths in Iraq and Afghanistan are God’s punishment for the U.S. tolerating homosexuality. The video parody says that “God hates the world and all her people” because of their wickedness.

“It’s all our religious doctrine,” said Shirley Phelps-Roper, church attorney and daughter of the pastor. “It’s our religious preachment. It’s all our effort to deliver a faithful message to this generation.”

But Warner/Chappel Music Inc. in Los Angeles views the video as infringing on the copyright it administers for “We Are the World.” The song raised money for famine relief that led to a video featuring some of American music’s biggest stars, including Ray Charles, Stevie Wonder and Bruce Springsteen.

“According to our records, no request has been made to use the Composition, no authorization has been granted nor has any license been issued for the use of the Composition on the Web site,” Kelly Isenberg, the company’s director of legal and business affairs wrote in a May 8 letter to the church.

Her letter demanded that the church stop using the parodied song “in any manner” and issue a statement under oath that the song “will not be exploited in any manner whatsoever” without prior written permission.

Isenberg wasn’t available for comment in her Los Angeles office and didn’t return a telephone message from the Associated Press.

The parody follows the “We Are the World” video’s format of showing a group of singers — Westboro Baptist members — in front of a microphone. The rewritten lyrics include: “You are all a part of the devil’s family and the truth, you’re all headed straight to hell!”

“The visual imagery was as important as the sound,” Phelps-Roper said. “We thought, ‘You can’t do this parody without having the visual element.’”

During their pickets, Westboro Baptist members often sing parodies of patriotic, military or popular songs. For example, to the tune of “America the Beautiful,” they sing their own lyrics, “Wicked Land of Sodomites.”

In a reply to Isenberg’s letter, dated May 17, the church’s pastor cited court decisions from 1980, 1994 and 2002 in arguing that the parody isn’t subject to copyright laws. Phelps-Roper said the parody would be protected even if the church was trying to sell its video, which it isn’t.

“It’s lame. All of it’s lame,” she said of the music company’s arguments. “They know perfectly well that we have proper parody. They don’t like the words.”

Westboro Baptist’s picketing of soldiers’ funerals led Congress and at least 34 states, including Kansas, to enact laws attempting to restrict such protests.


Related

Pastor's anti-gay actions test society's commitment to First Amendment

By David L. Hudson Jr. 'The true test of free speech is whether we tolerate political ideas which we all consider offensive,' says law professor. 10.16.98

Veteran songwriter: Political ad's music violates copyright
Rebuffing Graham Nash's claims, firm that backed TV commercial says few seconds of music in ad represent 'classic fair use.' 08.11.03

Bush signs bill barring protests at military funerals
Measure restricts demonstrations at national cemeteries an hour before and after burial services. 05.30.06

Judge suspends Ky. ban on funeral protests
Ruling that law forbidding demonstrations within 300 feet of military services is too broad results in temporary suspension. 09.27.06

Trial date set for defamation suit against anti-gay church
Jury trial, expected to last two weeks, is scheduled to begin Oct. 22 in case stemming from Westboro Baptist Church's protest at Marine's funeral. 03.05.07

McCain ad strikes wrong chord, singer-songwriter says
Jackson Browne files lawsuit, claiming use of 'Running on Empty' in ad was infringement of his copyright and will lead people to conclude he endorses Republican presidential hopeful. 08.18.08

Copyright & the First Amendment
By David L. Hudson Jr. Oftentimes, particularly in the age of the Internet, copyright and the First Amendment collide. 08.05.04

Parody & satire

Funeral protests


News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print


Last system update: Thursday, August 21, 2008 | 10:49:23
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

First Reports
Supreme Court
Experts
Columnists
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Sings™
Events
First Amendment
Schools

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links