First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
Kan. man fined for anti-war signs in his yard

By The Associated Press
12.28.05

PRAIRIE VILLAGE, Kan. — A suburban Kansas City man is appealing a ticket Prairie Village gave him for homemade yard signs opposing the war in Iraq.

The American Civil Liberties Union of Kansas and Western Missouri is helping David Quinly appeal the citation in Johnson County District Court. Quinly sought the ACLU's help after losing an appeal in municipal court.

At issue is a Prairie Village ordinance prohibiting signs bigger than 5 square feet and limiting the total area of temporary signs displayed on a property to 10 square feet. Signs can't be up more than 60 days.

"It's clearly a First Amendment issue," said Quinly's attorney, John Simpson. "We think ... that the Prairie Village sign ordinance is too restrictive."

Quinly had been putting up anti-war signs in his yard since before the U.S. entered Iraq. He was warned two signs exceeded the size limit, but he kept them up, believing any resulting fine would be $20 or $30. After he was cited Sept. 20, he was surprised to find out the fine was $300, an amount he considered excessive.

Quinly said he understood why cities restrict signs, but said political signs should be less restricted than others, not more.

Simpson said he would argue that Prairie Village restricts political signs more than other signs; the U.S. Supreme Court has deemed such content-based discrimination unconstitutional.

"You've discriminated, in effect, against political speech, which is the speech most protected in our (First) Amendment," Simpson said.

Issues surrounding temporary signs don't usually apply to commercial signs, said City Attorney Charles Wetzler.

The ordinance says sign placement and size must be restricted to prevent them from creating traffic hazards. The sign ordinance also seeks to prevent "visual clutter" in neighborhoods.

"The law changes all the time in this area," Wetzler said, noting the latest version of the ordinance was drafted with the ACLU's input. "There have been new cases that come out, and if we need to look at it, we will."

University of Kansas law professor Mike Kautsch said it was not unusual for cities to limit signs for aesthetic reasons. But, he said, "If it's on a matter of public concern, the courts are usually going to be quite protective on the matter of a yard sign."

"The idea is to make sure these ordinances are clearly content-neutral, that they don't restrict a sign in any way because of the nature of that message," Kautsch said.


Update
Kansas City suburb may go back to drawing board on sign rules
Federal judge blocks enforcement of Prairie Village, Kan., ordinance used by city to cite resident for anti-war yard signs. 09.05.06

Related

Ohio couple fight to display large Bush-Cheney sign

Alex and Karen Arshinkoff say ordinance that limits size of Hudson residents' yard signs violates free speech. 10.17.04

Political yard signs OK'd in 2 Detroit suburbs
Federal judge issues temporary injunction barring enforcement of Troy's sign law; meanwhile, Grosse Pointe Woods revokes part of its ordinance. 10.20.04

Ohio residents challenge political yard-sign restrictions
Federal judges order two towns to halt enforcement of rules; hearing set to examine another city's ordinance. 10.25.04

Town’s political yard sign restriction struck down
Ordinance allowing lawn signs to be posted only for 30 days before elections ruled unconstitutional. 07.22.05

Idaho man files $1 million legal claim over libel arrest
L.D. Bryson was arrested after he put up yard signs intended to make neighbors aware of sex offenders. 01.04.06

Political yard signs

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print


Last system update: Wednesday, August 20, 2008 | 20:59:26
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

First Reports
Supreme Court
Experts
Columnists
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Sings™
Events
First Amendment
Schools

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links