First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
Anti-milk yearbook ad riles administrators' bile

By The Associated Press

FRESNO, Calif. — In farm-rich Central California, administrators at one Fresno high school can't swallow the yearbook's picture of a chubby teenager spewing milk from his nose.

A team headed by Assistant Principal John Leal has ripped out the page of the Roosevelt High School yearbook that displays an ad warning readers, "If you knew how cows suffered, you'd spew."

The $250 ad was paid for by the animal-rights group People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. The ad directs students to PETA's anti-milk campaign Web site,, which shows cows held in pens full of excrement and lists a series of health problems the group argues are associated with milk consumption.

"The district was concerned that the yearbook was used as a political platform for a point of view that neither the district nor the school supported," Leal said on May 20. "We're in the heart of the San Joaquin Valley. We have hundreds of dairies all around. We're certainly not anti-milk."

Cattle and dairy is a $6 billion industry in California, and the state leads the nation in dairy production. In Tulare County, south of Fresno County, dairy generates almost $1 billion a year, making it the highest producing dairy county in California and perhaps the nation, according to county Assistant Agricultural Commissioner Bill Appleby.

Local producers don't want PETA's no-dairy message anywhere near school cafeterias.

"Free speech underpins our republic, but some folks take advantage of it," said Michael Walsh, CEO of the Western United Dairymen trade group. "It is concerning that they've infiltrated our high schools and are attempting to spread their message of terror there as well."

PETA officials aren't impressed.

"It is sad that any so-called educator would censor ideas that promote compassion and good health," said Bruce Friedrich, a national director with the group. He said he suspected kids would be even more interested in the message now that an authority figure has criticized it.

Leal said the student who sold the ad didn't know what PETA was and didn't understand the political message. About 300 yearbooks were distributed on May 19 still containing the full-page parody of the "Got Milk?" ads, but Leal and other school officials tore the ad out of the 400 yearbooks that were left.

Friedrich said the ad had been published in other yearbooks and school newspapers, and that reaction from the students had been positive.

The school took action after the Fresno Unified School District alerted administrators about concerns from the community, Leal said. The school will return $1,000 to businesses advertising on the back of the full-page PETA ad and $250 to PETA, Leal said.

At least one Roosevelt student said school administrators were crying over spilled milk.

"They're blowing the whole thing out of proportion," said Tamarra Daniels, a sophomore, who was sitting with her friend looking at the yearbook. "It's not like we're not going to drink milk."


Pet rat, class sweethearts stir up controversy

Principal in Oregon won't allow picture of teen and 'Rotten Rat' in yearbook; New Hampshire superintendent OKs listing of lesbians as class favorites. 12.05.01

Florida student sues after being left out of yearbook
Teen's photo wasn't taken after she opted not to comply with administrators' demand that she wear 'scoop neck drape' as did other girls. 06.23.02

California high court steers clear of 'happy cow' lawsuit
Lower court had rejected PETA claim, found Milk Producers Advisory Board was immune from being sued under false-advertising laws. 04.22.05

Calif. school restores religious references to yearbook ads
Conservative legal group had threatened to sue if district didn't have original ads reprinted. 03.12.07

Dairy producers demand end to Got Milk? knockoff
PETA contends there's no way consumers would be so confused as to think industry is behind 'Got pus? Milk does' slogan. 12.13.07

K-12 newspapers & yearbooks

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Thursday, August 21, 2008 | 10:26:24
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Singsā„¢
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links