First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
Court ruling may force FEC to regulate Web political activity

By The Associated Press

Editor's note: The Associated Press reported that U.S. District Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly on Oct. 19 denied the FEC's request that she temporarily set aside her September ruling striking down several government rules on political fund raising. Kollar-Kotelly, though denying the FEC's request that she stay the ruling pending the outcome of the commission's appeal in the case, said the FEC rules she overturned would nonetheless remain "on the books" until the commission writes new ones.

WASHINGTON — With political fund raising, campaign advertising and organizing taking place in full swing over the Internet, it may just be a matter of time before the Federal Election Commission joins the action. Well, that time may be now.

A recent federal court ruling says the FEC must extend some of the nation's new campaign-finance and spending limits to political activity on the Internet.

Long reluctant to step into online political activity, the agency is considering whether to appeal.

But vice chairwoman Ellen Weintraub said the Internet may prove to be an unavoidable area for the six-member commission, regardless of what happens with the ruling.

"I don't think anybody here wants to impede the free flow of information over the Internet," Weintraub said. "The question then is, where do you draw the line?"

This election season has been a groundbreaking one online, as interest groups, campaigns and political parties use Web sites and e-mail to advertise, organize volunteers, reach out to donors and collect information about voters.

Former Democratic presidential hopeful Howard Dean made the most pronounced splash online when he stunned his rivals by raking in tens of millions of dollars through Web-a-thons, a far cheaper fund-raising method than traditional dinners and cocktail parties. And Internet message boards, known as blogs, have become as common a place for people to air their political views as talk shows and newspaper editorial pages.

The Internet also is where political players do what they can no longer do on television or radio.

The National Rifle Association, for example, has started an online newscast and talk show to air its views on presidential and congressional candidates. The Internet is exempt from a ban on the use of corporate money for radio and TV ads targeting federal candidates close to elections, part of the new campaign finance law that took effect this election cycle.

The November Fund, an anti-trial lawyer group partly funded by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, is posting Internet ads criticizing Democratic vice presidential nominee John Edwards, a North Carolina senator and former personal-injury lawyer.

The FEC exempted such ads from the law's ban on coordination between candidates and groups that raise or spend corporate money. Last month, U.S. District Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly struck down the coordination exemption, ruling that it "severely undermines" the law.

Fred Wertheimer, president of the campaign watchdog group Democracy 21 and member of the legal team that successfully sued to overturn that and several other FEC rules interpreting the law, said campaign-finance laws should apply to the Internet because substantial amounts of money are being spent on online at election time.

The laws may not always apply to the Internet as they would to other venues, Wertheimer said, "but by the same token the Internet cannot become a major avenue for evading and circumventing campaign-finance laws on the grounds that people just want the Internet free from regulation of any kind."

Max Fose, a Republican Internet consultant who helped Arizona Sen. John McCain, a sponsor of the new campaign finance law, raise millions of dollars online for his 2000 presidential bid, is wary of the judge's ruling.

"Whenever there's something new and emerging and it's still developing, to place restrictions on it I think is going to hurt how political candidates and elected officials look to use the Internet, to not only be elected but look to get voters involved," Fose said.

D.C. Circuit questions FEC interpretation of campaign-finance rules
Two judges on three-member panel suggest agency has defined terms too narrowly, making it easy to circumvent Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act. 05.13.05

Court scraps more than a dozen campaign-finance rules
Federal judge orders FEC to write new regulations to govern key aspects of fund raising, including when candidates, outside parties can coordinate activities. 09.20.04


McCain gains ally in drive to block big campaign money

Sen. Trent Lott, R-Miss., opposed the McCain-Feingold law but now supports further legislation to stop groups from circumventing rules. 02.03.05

Bloggers go mainstream to fight regulation
Several Web log founders testify at hearing on FEC proposal that would extend some campaign-finance rules to Internet. 06.29.05

Political bloggers say FEC shouldn't regulate their speech
Echoing bloggers, commission vice chairman urges House panel to pass law that pre-empts court decision ordering agency to extend campaign-finance rules to Web. 09.23.05

Campaign finance overview

Online campaign ads

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Thursday, August 21, 2008 | 18:00:35
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links