First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
Hawaii legislators pass journalist shield bill

By The Associated Press

HONOLULU — Hawaii journalists would be protected from revealing their sources, notes and video recordings to the government under a measure given final approval by lawmakers yesterday.

The proposal covers both traditional reporters and online writers, although Internet journalists would have to show that they were serving the public interest before they would be granted the safeguard.

"They need a shield. They need protection to go out and continue doing what they're doing," said state Rep. Gene Ward, R-Kalama Valley-Hawaii Kai.

Thirty-five other states and the District of Columbia have similar protections, and a federal shield law is pending before Congress.

Hawaii lawmakers approved the measure unanimously in both the state House and Senate, and it now goes to Gov. Linda Lingle for her signature.

Some representatives said they were concerned the privilege exempting journalists from having to give up their sources to courts and local governments could be abused by unscrupulous Internet writers.

"They look like journalists but are not held to the same ethical standards," said state Rep. Barbara Marumoto, R-Kalani Valley-Diamond Head. "True professional journalists ... are accountable to their editors or their viewers."

H.B. 2557 would protect any reporter who has ever worked for a newspaper, magazine, news agency, radio station or television station. It covers online writers only if they hold a similar job as traditional journalists and regularly publish news in the public interest.

Hawaii prosecutors agreed to the measure after carving out exemptions for felony cases, civil actions involving defamation, public safety, source consent to disclosure and when the desired information is necessary to an investigation or defense.

State Rep. Joe Souki, D-Waihee-Wailuku, said additional shield protections go too far because reporters are already covered by the First Amendment's guarantee of freedom of the press.

"I haven't seen any reporter taken off and put in jail," Souki said. "The shield law is going beyond what is needed."

Without a shield law, journalists are sometimes jailed for contempt of court when they refuse to comply with a judge's order to name names.

Malia Zimmerman of is fighting a subpoena of her notes and records from her investigative reporting into the March 14, 2006, failure of Kaloko Dam on Kauai, which unleashed a 20-foot-high wave of water that killed seven people as they slept.

Her reporting tools are being sought by the dam's owner, James Pflueger, as he builds his defense against lawsuits from the victims' families.

Hawaii Senate panel endorses reporter shield law
Judiciary Committee adopts version of bill favored by news media, giving journalists broad safeguards from being forced to turn over materials to courts, prosecutors or police. 04.07.08


Hawaii court considers whether Web site reporter is a journalist

If Malia Zimmerman clears that hurdle, circuit judge will then decide if she has qualified privilege to refuse to provide confidential information to lawyers in civil case. 05.21.07

Bush officials mount campaign against media-shield bill
In letters to senators, Attorney General Michael Mukasey, others say measure could harm national security, would encourage more leaks of classified data. 04.04.08

State shield statutes & leading cases
By Bill Kenworthy State-by-state compilation of journalist-shield statutes, cases. 10.17.05

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Thursday, August 21, 2008 | 18:14:31
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Singsā„¢
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links