First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
Va. bill would allow trespass charges against reporters

By The Associated Press
01.24.07

RICHMOND, Va. — A state senator has proposed legislation that would allow trespassing charges to be filed against "scuzzball reporters" who enter private property to gather news about a death or other traumatic event.

Although state Sen. Kenneth T. Cuccinelli's bill targets journalists, it also could make criminals of virtually anyone else who ventures onto the traumatized person's property — door-to-door salesmen and delivery drivers, for example.

Cuccinelli, R-Fairfax, said he plans to amend the bill, SB 1120, to make it clear that a friend or acquaintance who drops by would not be trespassing. His goal, he said, is "to keep reporters from bugging people" who are grieving.

"There's obviously more than enough scuzzball reporters out there who don't have a shred of human decency to give a flying rat's tail about the condition or feelings or circumstances of these families — they just want a juicy quote from them," Cuccinelli said. "If they are not going to regulate themselves, it's our job to protect the people of Virginia."

Ginger Stanley, executive director of the Virginia Press Association, says the bill infringes on the U.S. Constitution's guarantee of freedom of the press.

"It's a direct attack on First Amendment newsgathering activity," she said.

Cuccinelli disagrees.

"Nobody has a right to come onto somebody's property. Show me where that's in the First Amendment," he said.

Under state law, a person can be charged with trespassing only if he's been directly told to stay away or if a sign is posted prohibiting entry to the property. Cuccinelli's proposed amendment to that law, however, would make entry illegal within a week after the resident "suffered a substantial personal, physical, mental, or emotional loss, injury or trauma," provided the visitor knew or should have known about the trauma.

Stanley said that along with the constitutional concerns, the legislation is fraught with practical difficulties. For example, what constitutes a substantial emotional loss?

"It could be a child who lost a pet," she said.

And, Stanley wondered, is word-of-mouth or a news report about an incident enough to establish that the visitor should have known about the trauma?

"There are no parameters or definitions around this," she said.

Cuccinelli said visitors who demonstrate sensitivity have nothing to fear from his bill.

"The citizen doesn't have to complain, this just gives them the ability to do it," he said. "People who are being reasonable and conducting themselves in a decent manner, there's no reason you'd expect anyone would be tagged with trespass under those circumstances."

Stacy Ruble of the Virginia Sexual and Domestic Violence Action Alliance says her organization has no position on the bill, but she doesn't believe reporters as a rule are insensitive to crime victims.

"I don't think I'd make that generalization," Ruble said.


Update
Va. lawmaker finds no support for reporter-trespass bill
News-media groups, committee counsel criticize proposal; fellow state senator says: 'I never heard of such a gratuitous, wholesale attack on the press.' 01.25.07

Related

Newspaper's reporting, police reaction after fire chief's suicide prompts First Amendment questions

An angry family, published excerpts from a suicide note, and a major conflict with law enforcement in Meriden, Conn. 09.03.02

Tribal police arrest journalists covering school shooting
'The media shouldn't be censored like this,' says one victim's family member. 'The families want people to know about their loved ones.' 03.23.05

When privacy and press rights collide
By Paul K. McMasters The facts around it have grown fuzzy and faded with the passage of 30 years but the singular image is as sharp today as it was the night it was imprinted in my memory. 03.29.99

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print


Last system update: Thursday, August 21, 2008 | 18:14:37
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

First Reports
Supreme Court
Experts
Columnists
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Singsā„¢
Events
First Amendment
Schools

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links