First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
Ariz. man sued for selling anti-war T-shirts

By The Associated Press

PHOENIX — A Tennessee couple whose soldier son was killed in Iraq want to expand their lawsuit against an Arizona online merchant of anti-war T-shirts to cover more than 4,000 casualties and seek more than $40 billion in damages.

An amended complaint filed on behalf of Robin and Michael Read of Greeneville, Tenn., seeks to make the lawsuit against Dan Frazier of Flagstaff a class-action case.

With the change, it would cover the heirs of all U.S. service members killed in the Middle East since Sept. 11, 2001, and seek $4 billion of compensatory damages and $36.5 billion of punitive damages.

The Reads’ original lawsuit named only themselves as plaintiffs and sought $10 million in compensatory and punitive damages.

Frazier’s “Bush lied — They died” T-shirts list Iraq war casualties’ names, and Frazier contends he is covered by First Amendment free-speech protections.

“We think it will be clear that this is political expression and not done for profit,” said Lee Phillips, Frazier’s attorney.

The Reads’ amended complaint filed April 29 in federal court in Tennessee says Frazier has no right to make a profit from commercial sale of products using the casualties’ names without permission.

That is a concept “that even a mentally-challenged monkey could grasp,” but Frazier had been quoted in an Associated Press article as saying he was not worried by the original suit, the amended lawsuit stated.

With the expanded dollar amounts of damages, “even the aforesaid ‘mentally challenged monkey’ should be worried about potential exposure in this amount,” the suit concluded.

Once served with the suit, Frazier will ask that it be transferred to the federal court in Arizona, which has already begun considering Frazier’s challenge to an Arizona law barring use of slain service members’ names for commercial purposes without permission, Phillips said.

A federal judge in Arizona said in a preliminary ruling that a portion of the Arizona law making violations a misdemeanor crime violates the First Amendment.

Arizona is among several states that have enacted similar laws.

Though it would probably be as much of a hardship for the Reads to have their case decided in Arizona as it would be for Frazier to have it heard in Tennessee, it makes sense for the Arizona court to handle the case because of related work done on the Frazier lawsuit, Phillips said.

The Reads’ attorney, Frank Santore, said in an e-mail that court rules barred him from comment.


Okla. woman fights to keep son's name off anti-war T-shirts

Judy Vincent, whose Marine son died in Iraq, successfully pushed for state law restricting use of soldier's name, likeness; similar federal measure introduced. 07.25.06

States crack down on T-shirts showing dead soldiers
Several more states moving to outlaw commercial use of names of fallen troops without families' permission. 05.21.07

Federal court puts hold on Ariz. law targeting anti-war T-shirts
Judge issues preliminary injunction, says shirts displaying names of U.S. soldiers killed in Iraq are political speech. 09.28.07

N.H. House moves to protect fallen soldiers' images
Bill opponent argues restrictions ignore the Constitution the soldiers died to protect. 02.10.08

Federal judge: Man's anti-war T-shirts express 'core political speech'
Arizona can't prosecute Dan Frazier under state law that bars sale of products that use military casualties' names without families' permission. 08.21.08

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Thursday, August 21, 2008 | 20:59:41
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links