First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
Bush asks Supreme Court to preserve 'under God' in pledge

By The Associated Press
05.01.03

WASHINGTON — The Bush administration appealed to the Supreme Court yesterday to preserve the phrase "under God" in the Pledge of Allegiance recited by school children.

The reference does not amount to unconstitutional government promotion of religion, the administration's top Supreme Court lawyer wrote in a court filing that sides with a Sacramento-area school district.

"Whatever else the (Constitution's) establishment clause may prohibit, this court's precedents make clear that it does not forbid the government from officially acknowledging the religious heritage, foundation and character of this nation," Solicitor General Theodore Olson wrote in the filing.

"That is what the Pledge of Allegiance does. The pledge is therefore constitutional."

The Justice Department and the Elk Grove Unified School District asked the high court to reverse a federal appeals court ruling last year that banned the teacher-led pledge in public schools.

The First Amendment to the Constitution says the government may not establish religion. In practice that has meant the government cannot endorse or promote religion in general, or favor one religion over another.

The Supreme Court has twice declared the pledge constitutional, and numerous justices have assumed as much in other writings, Olson argued. He suggested that the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals was so far out of bounds in its Elk Grove ruling that the Supreme Court could simply strike down the decision without hearing arguments on the case.

The administration asked the Court to hear its appeal in this year's fall term. The Court could decide before summer whether to take the case.

In March, the sharply divided San Francisco-based appeals court voted not to reconsider its earlier ruling on the pledge. In the initial ruling last June, two judges on a three-judge panel ruled that the regular morning classroom salute to the American flag is unconstitutional because of the phrase "one nation, under God."

The ban is on hold while the school district appeals. The Bush administration joined the case and filed its own appeal. If allowed to take effect in the nine states covered by the 9th Circuit, the pledge ban would affect 9.6 million children in public schools.

The appeals-court ruling was widely denounced in Congress, on opinion pages and at the White House.

"Our religious heritage has been recognized and celebrated for hundreds of years," in the national motto "In God We Trust," the national anthem and elsewhere, Attorney General John Ashcroft said after the appeal was filed yesterday. "Our government and people can acknowledge the important role religion has played in America's foundation, history and character," he said.

The case began when Michael A. Newdow, a California man who describes himself as an atheist, sued the school district where his daughter was a second-grader.

The Supreme Court has already ruled that children cannot be forced to recite the pledge (in West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette, 1943). If they object to it, they may stand by in silence, the Court has said.

But Newdow argued that that wasn't good enough. He contended that his daughter's constitutional right to religious liberty was violated by hearing the pledge recited in school, where it obviously carried the stamp of government approval.

The 9th Circuit agreed.

"The coercive effect of the policy here is particularly pronounced in the school setting given the age and impressionability of schoolchildren, and their understanding that they are required to adhere to the norms set by their school, their teacher and their fellow students," the appeals court panel wrote.


Update
Supreme Court takes up Pledge of Allegiance fight
Justices agree to consider whether 'one nation under God' should remain part of patriotic oath as it is recited in most classrooms. 10.14.03

Previous
House condemns appeals court over Pledge of Allegiance ruling
Meanwhile, Utah's governor signs bill requiring weekly recitation of oath by state's junior high, senior high school students. 03.21.03

Related

9th Circuit stays Pledge of Allegiance ruling

Order gives California school district 90 days to ask Supreme Court to review decision that phrase 'under God' amounts to government endorsement of religion. 03.05.03

Congressman pushes bill limiting court review of Pledge
Law professor says measure allowing only Supreme Court to review challenge of Pledge of Allegiance would 'undermine the traditional role of the federal courts in protecting the Bill of Rights.' 05.12.03

White House asks high court to stay out of abortion-protest case
Administration says justices should let stand ruling against abortion foes for listing personal data about abortion-clinic employees on Web, posters. 06.03.03

ACLU challenges Colorado's Pledge of Allegiance law
'Public expressions of belief in the ideals of liberty and justice should be voluntary, not coerced,' says group's legal director. 08.13.03

Colorado Pledge of Allegiance law put on hold
Federal judge issues temporary injunction, saying statute requiring public school students, teachers to recite oath is discriminatory and divisive. 08.18.03

White House urges high court to allow state aid for religious studies
Meanwhile, California man who wants 'under God' removed from Pledge asks Justice Antonin Scalia to stay out of case because of remarks he made at religious event. 09.11.03

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print


Last system update: Thursday, August 21, 2008 | 21:40:02
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

First Reports
Supreme Court
Experts
Columnists
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Sings™
Events
First Amendment
Schools

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links