First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
Student sues over suspension for wearing anti-gay shirt

By The Associated Press

LOS ANGELES — A San Diego County school district was sued this week for allegedly violating the civil rights of a student who was suspended for wearing a T-shirt reading “Homosexuality is Shameful.”

A federal lawsuit filed June 2 against the Poway Unified School District says Tyler Chase Harper was suspended for expressing his “sincerely held religious beliefs” during and after an April 21 “Day of Silence.” During the national event, high school and college students remain silent to show support for homosexuals, bisexuals and trans-gender students.

The suit was filed in U.S. District Court in Los Angeles.

“Because it’s a legal matter, the district is unable to comment,” said Sharon Raffer, spokeswoman for the 32,000-student school district.

Harper, 16, of Poway, is a sophomore at Poway High School. According to the suit, he is a Christian who believes that “homosexual behavior is immoral, damaging to the practitioners and to human society in general, and is demonstrably contrary to the teachings of the Bible.”

According to the suit, on April 21 he wore a T-shirt hand-lettered with the words “I Will Not Accept What God Has Condemned” on the front, and on the back it read “Homosexuality is Shameful” and “Romans 1:27,” a reference to a Bible passage.

When he wore a similar shirt the next day, a classroom teacher told him that he was violating the school dress code and must remove the T-shirt or go to the office, according to the lawsuit.

The suit claims that the school’s assistant principal said the shirt violated the code because it had homemade printing and was “inflammatory,” and that the teenager was suspended by the principal when he refused to remove it.

The lawsuit also contends that a sheriff’s deputy whom it did not identify told the student that the shirt “could encourage uprising and violence against homosexuals” and that a school vice principal said he must “leave his faith in the car.”

According to the lawsuit, Poway High School’s student policy handbook states that the dress code forbids “violence or hate behavior, including derogatory connotations directed toward sexual identity.” It alleges the policy is too broad and vague.

The school district policy forbids expressions of “racial, ethnic, or religious prejudice” that might create a “clear and present danger” of unlawful acts or disruption of school operations, the suit said.

But the lawsuit argues that Harper’s messages did neither.

“When are public school officials going to learn they are not allowed to silence constitutionally protected student speech just because they disagree with the student?” said a statement by Robert Tyler, a lawyer with the Alliance Defense Fund, which filed the suit.

The group is asking the court to bar the district and school from “selectively banning religious expression” and to grant at least $25,000 in damages.

The Scottsdale, Ariz.-based defense fund provides funding, training and legal aid to lawyers and others to defend what it defines as “the legal battle for religious freedom, sanctity of life, and the preservation of marriage and the family.”

The suit, which names the district and high school and various officials as defendants, alleges violation of the student’s rights of freedom of speech, freedom of religion and equal protection of the law.


Judge: Ban on 'Straight Pride' shirt violated student's rights

Officials at Minnesota school failed to demonstrate that teen's shirt could be disruptive, federal court rules. 01.18.02

ACLU challenges district's policy prohibiting gay-themed T-shirts
Missouri teen says school has allowed other students to wear anti-gay clothing; 'I just want the same right.' 11.24.04

Court sides with school on student's T-shirt
But in ruling school had right to make student cover images of drugs and booze, judge also says words are protected and that disciplinary action should be removed from student's record. 12.28.04

'Muzzle' awards spotlight school censorship
By David L. Hudson Jr. Thomas Jefferson Center bestows its 14th annual awards focusing on attempts to squelch free expression. 04.12.05

T-shirt rebellion in the land of the free
By Charles C. Haynes Students' shirts proclaim every conceivable cause — and schools should resist the urge to ban them. 03.14.04

Clothing, dress codes & uniforms

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Thursday, August 21, 2008 | 19:36:52
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links