First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
ACLU campaigns for Michigan towns to allow political yard signs

By The Associated Press

FERNDALE, Mich. — The American Civil Liberties Union is warning municipalities in southeastern Michigan that ordinances limiting the display of campaign signs on lawns are repressing freedom of expression.

With the Aug. 3 primary elections approaching, the ACLU sent out letters to the managers and mayors of 10 Oakland County communities to get them to change their yard-sign ordinances, The Daily Oakland Press reported for a July 1 story.

The organization reviewed ordinances throughout the county after receiving a complaint from a Ferndale resident who was ticketed for having more than one political sign in his yard last year.

The ACLU found that some cities restrict the size or number of political signs per yard, while others require residents to get permits before staking their political preferences in their lawns.

"That's certainly a way to kill free speech," Elsa Shartsis, who chairs the legal committee for the organization's Oakland County branch, told the Detroit Free Press.

She said that prohibiting residents from displaying campaign signs for any reason is a direct violation of the U.S. Constitution.

In addition to Ferndale, the ACLU sent letters to Novi, Oak Park, Rochester Hills, Orchard Lake, Royal Oak, South Lyon, Southfield, Waterford and Troy. The group says it hopes the cities will review and modify their ordinances.

If they don't, Shartsis says, the ACLU will assist those who are ticketed in fighting the citations in court.

Local officials said the sign ordinances are needed to keep their communities looking clean.

"We have a long record of making ordinance decisions based on aesthetics," said Ferndale City Manager Tom Barwin.

He said, however, that the city is considering changing its ordinance to allow owners of homes on corner lots to display two signs instead of one.

Other Oakland County municipalities are also weighing their options after receiving the letter.

"I gave a copy to our attorney and sent a copy to community planning for them to take a look at it," said Waterford Township Supervisor Carl Solden.

Solden said residents are able to put up signs 30 days before elections, and displays have to come down five days after elections.


Wisconsin county decides not to fine man for displaying Bush yard sign

Meanwhile, Florida resident says town’s sign ordinance violates First Amendment. 05.16.01

Federal judge: Wisconsin city's sign law stifled man's free speech
Court finds Pewaukee aldermen were wrong to block Walter Fiedorowicz from erecting political signs in his yard. 04.13.04

Towns warned that limits on political signs could violate free speech
Connecticut Civil Liberties Union sends letters to cities after threatening to sue Westport if it doesn't amend its yard-sign regulations. 07.28.04

Federal judge halts Michigan city's time limit on yard signs
Meanwhile, conflicts are springing up across the country over statutes that restrict campaign signs. 09.20.04

Yard-sign rules contested in another Detroit suburb
ACLU says Troy violated free speech by ticketing man for Bush sign. 09.28.04

Political yard signs OK'd in 2 Detroit suburbs
Federal judge issues temporary injunction barring enforcement of Troy's sign law; meanwhile, Grosse Pointe Woods revokes part of its ordinance. 10.20.04

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Thursday, August 21, 2008 | 23:06:22
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links