overviewfrequently asked questionscases & resources
8th Circuit: Student's gory essay qualifies as 'true threat'

By The Associated Press,
First Amendment Center Online staff

ST. LOUIS — The 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld the dismissal of a lawsuit brought by a Minnesota teen who was briefly held after writing a gory essay in which a student shoots a teacher.

The three-judge panel upheld the summary judgment of U.S. District Judge John Tunheim against former Cook County High School student David Riehm and his mother, Colleen.

They sued the Minnesota school district and Cook County for damages, alleging the case violated the teen's First Amendment rights, among other claims. The 8th Circuit panel rejected those claims in Riehm v. Engelking.

In late 2004 and early 2005, the then-17-year-old Riehm wrote three essays his creative writing teacher found disturbing. The last of them was a particularly gory account of a student shooting his creative writing teacher in the face.

Riehm was suspended from school and later held in a psychiatric unit for three nights before being released.

The unanimous panel ruled the essay was a "true threat" that was not protected by the First Amendment and that the district and county officials responded to it in good faith. The teacher “quite reasonably felt personally threatened,” the court wrote.


Justices turn away student's free-speech claim (news)
5th Circuit had sided with Louisiana school district, which expelled Adam Porter over his drawing of school soaked in gasoline and surrounded by armed students. 06.01.05

Student expression: free speech vs. safety? (news)
"Student Expression in the Age of Columbine" by David L. Hudson Jr. examines balance between First Amendment freedoms, school safety. 10.11.05

Prosecutors drop charges against student author of violent essay (news)
'I think that they reached the conclusion that we reached long ago, that he's not a threat,' says attorney for Illinois high school senior Allen Lee. 05.25.07

11th Circuit backs teen's suspension for penning violent story (news)
By Courtney Holliday Three-judge panel says Georgia high school didn't violate First Amendment by punishing girl for journal entry about student who dreams she kills teacher. 08.07.07

2nd Ariz. eighth-grader suspended for drawing images of gun (news)
Parents say punishment is overreaction by Florence school officials; district spokesman says cartoon content warranted suspension. 09.02.07

'Free writing' assignment shows just how un-free schools can be (commentary)
By Douglas Lee Nothing in Illinois student's essay or his past suggests serious expression of intent to harm. 04.30.07

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Friday, August 22, 2008 | 10:27:13
student expression issues >
Clothing, dress codes & uniforms
K-12 newspapers & yearbooks
Underground papers & off-campus speech
Book censorship
Hate speech & speech codes
Pledge of Allegiance in public schools
Speaking out in school