First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
Fla. judge to decide if 'Bully' game can be sold to minors

By The Associated Press

Editor's note: The Associated Press reported that Miami-Dade County Circuit Court Judge Ronald Friedman reviewed the game and said on Oct. 13 that he saw no reason to restrict sales and dismissed the complaint.

A circuit court judge in Florida said Oct. 11 that he would review the unreleased video game "Bully" to determine if it should be sold to consumers under age 18.

The review was ordered after a complaint filed in the 11th Judicial Circuit Court by attorney Jack Thompson, long an outspoken critic of the video-game industry. The complaint accuses "Bully" of being a "Columbine simulator" and inappropriate for children.

"Bully," scheduled to be released across the nation on Oct. 17 for the PlayStation 2 console, lets players act out the life of a 15-year-old student and decide how to deal with teachers and various social cliques at a boarding school.

"Bully" was created by Rockstar Games, known for its popular "Grand Theft Auto" crime sagas where players can choose to live by the rules or hijack cars and run down pedestrians.

A company spokesman had no immediate comment on the review.

In his complaint, Thompson said he was seeking to have the game's rating changed from "T," for teenagers age 13 and older. It also seeks to preemptively block the sale of the game in Florida by Rockstar's publisher, Take Two Interactive Software Inc., as well as retailers Wal-Mart Stores Inc. and GameStop Corp.

"How to plan your revenge and rehearse your bullying back strategies, that dynamic is something we don't need to be teaching," said Thompson, who hasn't seen or played the game.

Miami-Dade County Circuit Court Judge Ronald Friedman planned to begin reviewing the game yesterday in his chambers with the help of a representative from Take Two, said Vera Weisbrod, the judge's legal assistant.

She didn't know how long the process would take, but the game's creators have said completing it could take upward of 30 to 40 hours.

Rockstar was embroiled in a ratings controversy last year with its game "Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas" after a hacker uncovered a hidden sex scene.

The game, originally rated mature for players 17 and older, was changed to an adults-only rating by an industry-ratings group after the scene was disclosed. An updated version with the sex scene deleted was eventually distributed to retailers with a mature rating.


Federal judge puts brakes on Calif. video-game restrictions

Court finds industry groups challenging new state law banning sale or rental of violent games to minors are 'likely to succeed' on free-speech grounds. 12.23.05

'Grand Theft Auto' makers settle with FTC over sex content
Deal requires companies to properly notify consumers of racy content on future games, not to misrepresent rating or content descriptions. 06.12.06

Federal judge stops Minn. video-game law before it starts
Attorney general says he'll likely appeal ruling; industry attorney expresses doubts about state's chances, citing 8th Circuit's 2003 ruling on video games. 08.01.06

Court: State can't bar sales of violent video games to minors
Federal judge issues injunction, calling Louisiana law an 'invasion of First Amendment rights' of producers, retailers and the minors who play the games. 08.28.06

Okla. law restricting video games blocked
Federal judge agrees that law to prohibit sale of violent games to children infringes free expression. 10.16.06

Okla. video-game law violates free speech, federal judge rules
Court permanently enjoins state from enforcing ban on selling violent video games to minors, says there is no 'substantial evidence' such games are harmful to kids. 09.19.07

'Beer Pong' game's teen-friendly rating criticized
Connecticut attorney general says Entertainment Software Rating Board erred when it gave ‘T’ rating to video game premised on college drinking game. 07.09.08

Video-game ratings: a tool or a weapon?
By Paul K. McMasters Never does the ponderous machinery of government and commerce rev up so quickly as when the republic is threatened by, uh, sex. 07.31.05

The games censors play
By Paul K. McMasters Hysteria over new 'Bully' game ignores fact that it's hardly violent at all — and that crime stats suggest media violence hasn't translated into real violence. 10.22.06

Rating & labeling entertainment

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Monday, September 22, 2008 | 21:04:43
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links