First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
Judge's embroidered robe: next Ten Commandments flap?

By The Associated Press
12.29.04

ANDALUSIA, Ala. — A south Alabama judge's decision to wear a judicial robe embroidered with the Ten Commandments could spark another prolonged legal battle in the state, according to legal experts.

This time there will be another issue involved: personal expression.

Covington County Circuit Judge Ashley McKathan began hearing cases while wearing a robe embroidered with the Ten Commandments on Dec. 13, saying he felt compelled to defend his belief that modern law is based on Scripture.

Terry Butts, who helped defend Roy Moore in a judicial inquiry that led to Moore's removal as chief justice of Alabama's Supreme Court, said McKathan's situation was similar because both cases "have to do with the First Amendment right to acknowledge God."

"I think the chances of McKathan's case winding up in court are very good," Butts told the Mobile Register in a story on Christmas Day. "I am confident someone will file a complaint with the Judicial Inquiry Commission and/or in Circuit Court to have the robe with the Commandments removed. McKathan may well be successful this time due to the issue of self-expression."

McKathan told the Associated Press that the Ten Commandments represented the truth "and you can't divorce the law from the truth."

Moore was removed from the bench in 2003 for refusing to remove a Ten Commandments monument from the rotunda of the Alabama Judicial Building in Montgomery.

Bryan Fair, a professor and constitutional law expert at the University of Alabama, said the display on McKathan's robe could be seen as state sponsorship of a religious message. He predicted it would lead to another court battle.

"The state does not have a religion," Fair said. "When judges in the courtroom embrace one religion, they inherently reject the others. Judges are state representatives, and their judicial work is not religious work."

But others say McKathan's decision involves freedom of expression as well as separation of church and state because the Commandments display is on clothing, not a courtroom wall or in a lobby.

"It is a much more personal thing," said attorney Mike Jones, who also represented Moore during the judicial inquiry.

"Freedom of expression issues may play out with McKathan that were not involved in Moore's case. It will be interesting to see what transpires."

Cases pending from Texas and Kentucky before the U.S. Supreme Court should give some clarification on which displays are acceptable, Fair said.

McKathan has expressed his support for Moore, who rode into the state's highest court on a wave of support for his battle to display a Ten Commandments plaque in his Etowah County courtroom.

Jones said Moore's case began when several people complained that the monument was personally offensive to them. Andalusia attorney Riley Powell filed a motion objecting to McKathan's judicial robe and asking that his client's case be continued. He said McKathan denied both motions.


Previous
Judge embroiders Ten Commandments in gold on robe
When attorney objects to unusual display of religious codes, Alabama judge refuses to delay trial. 12.15.04

Related

Roy Moore urges Congress to protect religious expression

Ousted Alabama justice testifies as part of Senate panel discussion on 'Beyond the Pledge of Allegiance: Hostility to Religious Expression in the Public Square.' 06.09.04

Justices to scrutinize commandments displays
Announcement to consider Texas, Kentucky disputes puts high court in middle of politically sensitive issue. 10.12.04

Ala. judge's 'circle of prayer' prompts criticism
ACLU attorney says from what person who attended session described, 'this was grossly inappropriate judicial behavior.' 03.26.08

Ten Commandments, other displays & mottos

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print


Last system update: Monday, September 22, 2008 | 21:27:51
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

First Reports
Supreme Court
Experts
Columnists
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Singsā„¢
Events
First Amendment
Schools

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links