First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
Commentary
 
A right for one is a right for all
Inside the First Amendment

By Charles C. Haynes
First Amendment Center senior scholar
04.29.07

In theory, the government treats all religions equally in America. In practice, however, some religions are more equal than others.

But two victories by minority religious groups this month are small but significant steps toward leveling the religious-liberty playing field as promised in the First Amendment.

On April 23, Wiccans finally won their 10-year battle to have the symbol of their faith added to the list of 38 “emblems of belief” approved by the Department of Veterans Affairs for placement on government headstones and memorials.

A few days earlier, on April 17, a religious group called Summum won a key round in its fight to place monuments in Utah city parks alongside Ten Commandments monuments. (Summum, founded some 30 years ago, is difficult to summarize, but the group describes its beliefs as consistent with Gnostic Christianity.

The message to government officials in both cases is simple but profound: Under the First Amendment, a right for one is a right for all.

Wiccans shouldn’t have to file lawsuits (this one brought by Americans United for Separation of Church and State on their behalf) to be treated fairly by the government. But until lawyers got involved, the VA stonewalled repeated requests for approval of the pentacle — the five-pointed star that symbolizes the Wiccan faith.

All signs point toward government bias against Wicca. While the Wiccans waited for an answer year after year, other groups had their symbols recognized in a matter of weeks.

Now the settlement agreement filed with the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin requires that the government finally acknowledge the right of Wiccan soldiers to have pentacles placed on their headstones and plaques.

In the Summum case, a three-judge panel of the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals granted an injunction that would allow Summum to place its Seven Aphorisms in a public park in Pleasant Grove, Utah. The park already has a Ten Commandments monument donated years ago by the Fraternal Order of Eagles. Summum had argued that if the city allows one group to put up a monument in a public park, it must allow other groups the same opportunity.

Pleasant Grove officials could have avoided the problem entirely by not allowing any private groups to put up monuments in the park. Instead they decided that the Ten Commandments monument should be treated differently because of “historical relevance” to the city.

The court unanimously rejected that argument and ruled that “the city may further its interest in promoting its own history by a number of means, but not by restricting access to a public forum traditionally committed to public debate and the free exchange of ideas.”

These legal victories by Wicca and Summum are stark reminders to government officials that religious diversity in America goes far beyond the “Protestant, Catholic, Jewish” description of the nation popular in the 1950s. As Harvard University professor Diana Eck documents in A New Religious America, this is now the most religiously diverse place on earth.

As the religious playing field grows more crowded, the only way to avoid conflict and litigation is for the government to enforce the First Amendment ground rules without favoring one religion over others — or religion over non-religion.

It doesn’t matter whether the group is Wicca, Summum or any of the other hundreds of faiths in the United States, government officials are supposed to stay neutral toward religion. And that means — to invoke a virtue we learned in kindergarten — be fair to all.

Charles C. Haynes is senior scholar at the First Amendment Center, 1101 Wilson Blvd., Arlington, Va. 22209. E-mail: chaynes@freedomforum.org.


Related

10th Circuit backs Summum in fights with 2 Utah cities

Panel: Group likely to succeed in forcing Pleasant Grove to allow Seven Aphorisms next to Ten Commandments; sect may challenge Duchesne's sale of park land. 04.18.07

VA settles lawsuit with Wiccans over grave markers
Five-pointed star will be added to list of acceptable religious symbols, heading off federal lawsuit. 04.23.07

Orthodox Jew accuses VA hospital of pushing Christianity
David Miller, who has had three operations in Iowa facility in last two years, says he went hungry because hospital wouldn't serve him kosher food. 05.15.07

High court agrees to consider religious-monument dispute
Utah city has asked justices to overturn 10th Circuit decision that sided with group trying to get its 'Seven Aphorisms' displayed in municipal park. 03.31.08

Witch trials and tribulations in the land of the free
By Charles C. Haynes No matter what military officers, school principals or other officials think about Wicca, it's their constitutional duty to protect the religious freedom of all Americans, including witches. 04.01.07

Christian Embassy at the Pentagon: Too close for comfort?
By Charles C. Haynes There's nothing wrong with religious groups volunteering to provide spiritual support for military personnel — unless they are being sponsored or favored by officials. 08.19.07

Analysis/Commentary summary page
View the latest analysis and commentary throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print


Last system update: Monday, September 22, 2008 | 21:56:08
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

First Reports
Supreme Court
Experts
Columnists
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Sings™
Events
First Amendment
Schools

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links