First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
Jay Leno seeks leeway to continue Michael Jackson jokes

By The Associated Press

LOS ANGELES — Have you heard the one about Jay Leno, the gag order in the Michael Jackson case and the First Amendment?

For Leno, who has been subpoenaed for Jackson’s child-molestation trial, it’s no joke.

Attorneys for the star of NBC’s “The Tonight Show with Jay Leno” have asked Judge Rodney S. Melville to lift or clarify the gag order, saying it “could be interpreted to limit Mr. Leno’s ability to publicly speak about the trial.”

Leno’s motion, released by Santa Barbara County Superior Court yesterday, was filed Feb. 18, a day after his lawyers said his subpoena was served.

“This motion was made on the grounds that this court could not possibly have intended its gag order, which was issued more than a year ago, to limit public personalities like Mr. Leno from commenting on public proceedings in this case,” attorneys Theodore Boutrous and Michael H. Dore wrote.

Applying the gag order — which bars anyone involved in the case from discussing it outside court — to Leno would be prior restraint in violation of the First Amendment and the California Constitution, the motion said.

If the gag order is applied anyway, the motion said, the court should clarify that the order “only limits Mr. Leno’s ability to disclose evidence of which he may have direct, first-hand knowledge, assuming only for the sake of argument that any such evidence exists.”

The motion requests that Melville expedite action on the entertainer’s request.

In a statement today, NBC said it was confident the judge “did not intend the gag order to prevent Jay Leno from doing what he has always done, which is entertain the country every night with jokes and comments about current events and breaking news.”

Carrie Simons, a publicist for the show, said yesterday she could not comment on the matter because of legal concerns. She declined to say whether the subpoena had led Leno to change the contents of his nightly monologue of jokes.

If the order has given Leno pause, it’s hard to tell from his monologues. He’s regularly feasted on the trial and Jackson’s odd public image.

On the Jan. 31 show, Leno joked that Jackson’s bail was high because “the judge felt he was a flight risk.”

“You know, that he may try to take a spaceship back to his home planet.

“More problems today for Michael Jackson,” Leno said on the March 1 show. “Police now say he served alcohol to two more boys, two minors, in 2003 and he was sleeping with three other boys. So now not only is Michael creepy, he’s a little tramp, too.”

Jackson, 46, has pleaded not guilty to charges of molesting a boy, conspiracy and administering an intoxicating agent, alcohol, to his alleged victim.

Jackson’s defense contends the boy’s family targeted celebrities for fraud, in particular by using the fact that the child was a cancer patient.

Jackson attorney Thomas Mesereau Jr. said during his opening statement to the jury that the family sought money from Leno, who was so suspicious he called Santa Barbara police to report that “something was wrong. They were looking for a mark.”

Leno: no basis for gag order in Jackson case
'Tonight Show' comedian's attorneys tell court that jokes and humorous commentaries are First Amendment-protected speech. 03.10.05


Jackson trial opens amid access, records issues

Judge won't clear courtroom of press, observers for testimony of two accusers; he'll release indictment, grand jury transcripts when jury is seated. 01.31.05

Heard the one about the politician locked up for lame joke?
Seriously, wisecrack lands Otis 'Bullman' Hensley in Kentucky jail for three days before charge was dismissed. 08.26.08

World watching Michael Jackson trial: How much will it see?
By Douglas Lee Judge Melville has kept press shackled so far; ultimate loser is the public, which needs to know how well justice is working. 01.31.05

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Tuesday, September 23, 2008 | 01:09:33
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links