First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
Texas students sue university over free-speech rules

By The Associated Press

EL PASO, Texas — A University of Texas at El Paso policy requiring students to get permits for speeches and deliver them in "free-speech areas" is a violation of the First Amendment, according to a lawsuit filed by two students.

The lawsuit, filed by sophomore Ruben L. Reyes and junior Kristofer Johnson, names four UTEP administrators, including President Diana Natalicio, and members of the University of Texas System Board of Regents.

"I am amazed that people who presume to be teachers are limiting the rights of students in such an extreme and unreasonable way," said Maria Hernandez, an attorney representing the students. "If the regents will negotiate with us, we think we can probably reach a reasonable settlement."

Officials of the UT System declined to comment on the lawsuit.

However, UTEP Dean of Students William D. Schafer, who was named in the lawsuit, said the university supports "the free exchange of information and expression."

"I think this boils down to how does a university campus create an atmosphere where that can occur where you're not disrupting classes," Schafer told the El Paso Times in its March 7 editions.

Reyes, 29, who is running for a seat on the El Paso City Council and ran for the state office of comptroller on the Green Party ticket last year, said the lawsuit is a matter of checks and balances.

Reyes had submitted 24 requests for permits to have events in UTEP free-speech zones since Nov. 4, including one rally to discuss "Censorship on Texas Universities." All of those requests were denied, according to the lawsuit.

The lawsuit comes on the heels of two other cases in Texas — one at the University of Houston and one at the University of Texas at Austin — that challenge the constitutionality of free-speech zones on public university campuses.

In November, a University of Texas at Austin task force that included Doug Laycock, the law school associate dean, recommended loosening free-speech rules on campus in response to mounting criticism of school policies.


Student, anti-abortion group sue Texas college

Lawsuit claims University of Houston violated students' First Amendment rights by restricting location of graphic display. 02.05.02

Abortion foes challenge rules on campus demonstrations, exhibits
Federal lawsuit claims University of Texas officials repeatedly denied permits for Justice for All to stage exhibits that included photographs of aborted fetuses. 10.03.02

University of Maryland sued over free-speech zones
ACLU says campus policy limiting speakers, leafleting to two locations infringes on students' free expression. 03.07.03

Group challenges Pennsylvania college's speech codes
Foundation for Individual Rights in Education says lawsuit against Shippensburg University is first of many it plans to file across the country. 04.24.03

Texas lawmakers consider curbing use of campus speech zones
'This bill ensures that universities provide students with a chance to express their ideas without fear of being arrested or disciplined unfairly,' says measure's sponsor. 04.28.03

Civil liberties groups seek to topple Texas Tech's free-speech policy
Law student sues over university's limits on protest locations, also challenges school's speech code. 06.13.03

College students rally to abolish campus-speech zone
Southwest Missouri State junior leads effort to repeal policies that regulate when, where, how demonstrations can be held. 10.22.03

Political correctness squelching campus speech, group says
Watchdog organization FIRE tells Senate committee that efforts to promote diversity, sensitivity are restricting intellectual discourse. 10.30.03

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Tuesday, September 23, 2008 | 01:10:48
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Singsā„¢
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links