First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
Fox appeals $91,000 indecency fine for reality show

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON — Fox Broadcasting Co. yesterday said it would not pay fines totaling $91,000 for airing a reality show episode that included graphic sexual scenes at a bachelor party.

Fox is also asking the Federal Communications Commission to reconsider the fines on the 13-owned and affiliated stations that aired the “Married by America” episode.

Sinclair Broadcast Group and Mountain Licenses LP also will not pay fines for its stations.

“Fox believes that the FCC’s decision in this case was arbitrary and capricious, inconsistent with precedent and patently unconstitutional,” said Scott Grogin, the company’s senior vice president of corporate communications, in a statement.

The FCC fined the Fox stations $7,000 each for the hour-long episode of “Married by America” that included strippers and other scenes from bachelor and bachelorette parties. The agency had initially proposed a $1.2 million fine against 169 affiliates of Fox, a division of News Corp., that aired the since-canceled reality show. But, under a relatively recent policy, the agency said it would only fine stations in markets where viewers complained.

In its ruling, released Feb. 22, the FCC wrote that “by any reasonable definition” many of the activities at the parties constituted sexual activities.

Grogin would not comment on whether Fox would take the FCC to court if the companies lost the appeal.

ABC did just that, after filing an appeal of the FCC’s ruling involving an episode of “NYPD Blue” in which a woman’s bare buttocks were shown.

On Feb. 12, the FCC fined 44 ABC Television Network stations a total of $1.2 million over the 2003 broadcast. ABC, which is owned by Walt Disney Co., paid the fine, but is challenging the agency’s ruling in court.

In response to Fox’s refusal to pay, FCC spokeswoman Mary Diamond said, “We believe in enforcing indecency standards especially when children are watching.”

In the FCC ruling, TV stations in Des Moines, Iowa; Nashville; Detroit; Washington; Minneapolis; West Point, Miss.; Greenville, S.C.; Yakima, Wash.; Charleston W.Va.; Lansing, Mich.; Roanoke, Va.; Kansas City, Mo.; and Tampa, Fla. face fines.

The six-episode “Married by America” introduced a cast of single men and women and allowed viewers to match them up by popular vote. Five matched couples then went through some rituals of dating, debauchery, and some whipped cream, but none married.

Justice Department sues to collect indecency fines from Fox
Action follows FCC's move to return 'without consideration' appeal of decision that broadcasting company called 'arbitrary and capricious.' 04.07.08

Fox slapped with record indecency fine
Network official says company disagrees with FCC's finding that episode of 'Married by America' was indecent, but won't say if broadcaster will appeal nearly $1.2 million fine. 10.13.04


Supreme Court takes broadcast-indecency case

First such case in 30 years concerns FCC policy allowing fines against broadcasters for 'fleeting expletives' on their programs. 03.17.08

Justices to examine 'fleeting' expletives
By Tony Mauro Court agrees to review latest version of 30-year-old FCC rules against backdrop of vastly different media landscape. 03.18.08

Look for ’08 to be year of broadcast-regulation battles
By Gene Policinski Looming showdown likely will redefine what government can regulate regarding what we see and hear, not just on television but also in new media. 12.30.07

The FCC's Regulation of Indecency

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Thursday, November 13, 2008 | 09:26:41
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links