First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
Prior restraint lifted from Orlando's WKMG-TV

By Melanie Bengtson
First Amendment Center Online intern
02.15.07

A Florida television station forbidden to broadcast news reports about an election-law scandal can now air the stories after a judge altered his original injunction.

Florida 9th Circuit Court Senior Judge Rom Powell on Feb. 12 changed his initial injunction, saying WKMG-TV Channel 6 in Orlando could air some of its investigative reports about political consultant Doug Guetzloe. The reports were based on 84 boxes of documents that the station obtained at an auction.

The original injunction imposing prior restraint on WKMG was issued Feb. 2 and Powell initially refused to change his decision. WKMG filed an appeal in the 5th District Court of Appeal in Florida to vacate the order and allow the station to broadcast the reports.

Powell repealed most of his order, but said certain documents could not be revealed: Guetzloe’s and his immediate family’s medical records or papers related to mental and physical health, as well as any kind of communication between Guetzloe and his attorneys. Powell also required that the station give Guetzloe’s attorneys access to the documents.

A Florida state attorney has also filed a request in the 9th Judicial Circuit for WKMG to turn over the 84 boxes of material because they may contain evidence of crimes. Florida law allows reporters not to turn over information unless a judge rules that there is a compelling reason to subpoena. Judicial Circuit Judge Lisa Munyon said she would rule after she hears from Guetzloe’s attorneys.

According to its Web site, WKMG is appealing Powell’s latest ruling because the station says it still violates the First Amendment in that it would not allow reports containing medical information and communication between Guetzloe and his attorneys to air.

The station began broadcasting the reports on Feb. 12.

Melanie Bengtson is an intern at the First Amendment Center and a sophomore studying developmental politics at Belmont University.


Update
Fla. appeals court sides with TV station in document dispute
Political consultant fails to prove his privacy concerns should trump WKMG's First Amendment rights, judges rule. 10.09.07

Previous
Fla. TV station still under prior restraint
Judge refuses to lift order preventing WKMG in Orlando from broadcasting news reports about documents involved in election controversy. 02.09.07

Related

Kansas City newspapers ordered to remove stories from Web sites

County circuit judge also bars Star, The Pitch from publishing articles about utility that are based on confidential document. 03.05.07

Mo. appeals court lifts ban on 2 newspapers' utility stories
Brief order agrees with The Kansas City Star, The Pitch that judge's ruling caused them 'irreparable harm' with no adequate legal remedy. 03.07.07

Newspaper ordered to turn over records about estate dispute
State judge also tells San Antonio Express-News not to publish articles related to guardianship case of multi-millionaire rancher. 08.28.07

Injunction against Boston TV news broadcast lifted
WHDH-TV had been barred from reporting autopsy results showing two firefighters who died battling a blaze had intoxicants in their blood. 10.08.07

When courtrooms peer into newsrooms, watch out
By Gene Policinski A free, independent news media must stand apart from government to be effective — not be a source of notes, interviews, videotapes and other materials increasingly sought by judges and attorneys. 03.11.07

Prior restraint


News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print


Last system update: Thursday, November 13, 2008 | 20:36:55
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

First Reports
Supreme Court
Experts
Columnists
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Sings™
Events
First Amendment
Schools

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links