First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
Wis. lawmaker seeks to ax state's 'holiday' tree

By The Associated Press

Editor’s note: The state Assembly on Dec. 11 voted 84-12 to change the name of the holiday tree to the “Wisconsin State Christmas Tree.” To take effect, the change must be approved by the state Senate. However, a spokeswoman for the Senate majority leader said the Senate would not consider the proposal.

MADISON, Wis. — Oh, how the holidays can be stressful.

A debate over what to call the giant tree in the Capitol this time of year turned contentious during a public hearing on Nov. 28.

Rep. Marlin Schneider, D-Wisconsin Rapids, asked his colleagues to support his plan to rename the holiday tree the “Wisconsin State Christmas Tree.” He said the tree was known as a Christmas tree from 1916 until wobbly state officials changed its name in 1985.

“I am here today to voice the ire and frustration of the majority of people of the state of Wisconsin who want their Christmas tree back in the state Capitol, not a politically correct holiday tree,” Schneider said, nearly shouting.

But Annie Laurie Gaylor of the Freedom From Religion Foundation said lawmakers shouldn’t waste their time debating such trivial issues. Calling it a “Christmas” tree would offend nonreligious people and amount to a government endorsement of Christianity, she added.

“The state of Wisconsin cannot have a Christmas anything,” said Gaylor, whose Madison-based group represents atheists and agnostics.

Rep. Joel Kleefisch, R-Oconomowoc, wasn’t buying her argument. He said the word holiday itself “means holy day, representative of Christmas, the holiest day in the Christian calendar.”

“You will not be happy until we have a godless world,” he told Gaylor. “You ask for an unreasonable degree of political correctness.”

Gaylor shot back. “If you know you’re excluding people by calling it a Christmas tree, why should you do that? It’s impolite.”

Rep. Karl Van Roy, R-Green Bay, chairman of the Assembly committee on state affairs, said his committee and hopefully the full Assembly would approve Schneider’s plan before Christmas.

The tree this year is a 35-foot balsam fir. The Menominee Nation donated the tree, which was harvested on tribal land near Neopit. Workers moved the tree in Nov. 26, and an official lighting ceremony was scheduled for yesterday.

The Department of Administration says other religious symbols, including a menorah and a Baptist Church holiday sign, will be displayed in the Capitol in December. So will Gaylor’s group’s sign which calls religion “superstition that hardens hearts and enslaves minds.”

Schneider noted thousands of visitors come every year to see the tree, which is decorated with ornaments made by Wisconsin children and has a toy locomotive circling its base.

“If it looks like a Christmas tree, and it smells like a Christmas tree, and it’s decorated like a Christmas tree, and it has presents under it like a Christmas tree, (then) it’s a Christmas tree!” he shouted.


Christmas trees welcome again in Oregon city's buildings

Eugene officials had banned religious decorations — including trees — from public areas of city buildings, but revised policy classifies them as secular objects. 12.24.01

Mich. Capitol conifer re-christened 'Christmas tree'
'If you're going to have a tree, you might as well call it what it is,' Michigan Jewish Conference director says after lawmakers vote to change name. 11.30.06

'Tis the season for disputes over holiday observances
New Jersey town officials turn to state municipal league for guidance on how to handle religious displays on government property. 12.04.06

Christmas trees going back up at Sea-Tac
Rabbi who wanted menorah added to airport displays says he never wanted trees taken down. 12.12.06

Wash. state sued over denial of Nativity scene
Man asks federal court to end 'unauthorized prohibition of religious expression' at state Capitol in Olympia. 12.29.06

Christmas symbols back on display in Oklahoma City office
Holiday roundup: Items from around the nation about official displays, recognition of December religious holidays. 12.25.07

The war over Christmas: Who’s fighting and why?
By Charles C. Haynes This year the Christmas crusaders appear to be winning: Holiday is out, Christmas is in. 12.11.05

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Friday, November 14, 2008 | 01:09:17
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links