First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
Nashville voters defeat 'English First' proposal

By The Associated Press
01.23.09

NASHVILLE — Nashville voters yesterday rejected a proposal to make English the mandatory language for all government business, easing fears that the measure could damage the city's reputation and cost agencies millions in federal funding.

With 100% of precincts reporting early this morning, unofficial results showed the "English First" proposal losing with about 57% of voters against it and 43% in favor. Proponents said using one language would have united the city and saved money.

The city would have become the nation's largest to pass such a measure. Similar measures have passed elsewhere, though business leaders, academics, the city's mayor and Tennessee Gov. Phil Bredesen opposed the "English First" proposal, which the governor had called "mean-spirited."

"The results of this special election reaffirms Nashville's identity as a welcoming and friendly city, and our ability to come together as a community," Mayor Karl Dean said in a news release.

The referendum's leader, Metro Councilman Eric Crafton, had promoted it as a way to unite Nashville and prevent the kind of extensive translation services — and the associated expenses — provided by cities like New York or Los Angeles. He had pushed for English-only since 2006 and got the issue before voters through a petition drive.

"I support the collective wisdom of the voters. I am not going to bring English up again because the people of Nashville have spoken," Crafton said during a phone interview late last night.

It wasn't clear exactly how much translation would have been silenced had the measure passed. While it called for all government communication and publications to be printed in English, it would have allowed an exception for public health and safety.

Detractors also said the English First policy may not have survived a court challenge because Title VI of the Civil Rights Act requires agencies that receive federal dollars to provide free translation services.

For instance, health department spokesman Brian Todd said the agency could have lost up to $25 million in federal funds if it halted translation services.

The only documented expenditure is for Monterey, Calif.-based Language Line Services, which provides phone interpretations in 176 languages. Expenses for the service have totaled $522,287 since 2004. By comparison, the special election cost $300,000.

Nearly one in five registered voters cast ballots yesterday, a high turnout for a special election in Nashville. A total of 73,896 people cast ballots, compared with 51,484 people who voted in the last special election in 2005.

Supporter Glenda Paul, 35, said as she exited a voting precinct yesterday that having one language was an important part of keeping government small.

"If I moved to France to start a business, I would be expected to speak French and that doesn't mean that I am not welcome there," she said. "It just means I need to respect the language."

But Claire King, 31, who lives in East Nashville, said yesterday that she voted against the amendment because "it sends a message of intolerance."

The debate over establishing a national language is centuries old.

In 1780, John Adams proposed to the Continental Congress an academy be created to "purify, develop, and dictate usage of" English, the American Civil Liberties Union reported. His proposal was rejected as undemocratic.

Thirty states, including Tennessee, and at least a dozen cities have declared English their official language, said K.C. McAlpin, executive director of the Arlington, Va.-based ProEnglish. The organization contributed at least $19,000 to support the referendum. Opponents collected about $300,000.

About 10% of Nashville's nearly 600,000 people speak a language other than English in their homes, according to census data. The city is 5% Hispanic and home to the nation's largest Kurdish community and refugees from Southeast Asia, the Middle East and Africa.


Related

Nevada town repeals English-only law

Board of Pahrump repeals ordinance, never enforced, that made English official language, banned foreign flags flying solo. 02.18.07

Kan. official-English law takes effect today
New law says no state or local government agency is required to provide documents or hold meetings in any language except English — but nothing prevents them from offering documents in other languages or using interpreters. 07.01.07

Alaska's high court backs part of English-only law
But ruling strikes down central provision of state law requiring only English to be used for all government business. 11.06.07

Woman sues to block Nashville vote on 'English First'
Rosa Quinteros says in Chancery Court petition that charter amendment being voted on in January would violate her free speech. 11.20.08

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print


Last system update: Saturday, January 24, 2009 | 17:04:05
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

First Reports
Supreme Court
Experts
Columnists
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Singsā„¢
Events
First Amendment
Schools

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links