First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
Mich. bill aims to give sports fans more rights to cheer, jeer

By The Associated Press

LANSING, Mich. — Frustrated fans would have more freedom to express themselves in taxpayer-supported stadiums under legislation introduced by a Michigan lawmaker yesterday.

That includes fans carrying signs that criticize the home team.

The measure, HB 6466, is included in a sports fan "bill of rights" introduced by Republican state Rep. Leon Drolet of Macomb County's Macomb Township. Stadiums that get 20% or more of their funding from tax dollars could not confiscate signs unless they block other fans' view, contain profanity or pose a safety hazard.

The measure harkens back to last season at Ford Field, when angry Detroit Lions fans carried signs criticizing team president Matt Millen. Security personnel confiscated some 'Fire Millen' signs, although Ford Field officials also said some signs with pro-Lions messages have been confiscated for similar safety reasons.

"When taxpayers are paying to build these stadiums it is unbelievable that their basic rights of free speech and press would be squelched," Drolet said in a statement. "If stadiums want to prohibit such activity, they should not ask taxpayers to fund them."

Another bill, HB 6465, would prevent stadiums that receive public money from banning local news-media cameras or otherwise "unreasonably" restricting their access when that access is granted to network media.

HB 6467 is aimed at helping tailgaters supply their Sunday parties. The legislation would remove Michigan's prohibition on Sunday alcohol sales before noon, allowing the sales to begin at 7 a.m. instead.

Local governments could still pass and enforce their own laws to prevent Sunday morning alcohol sales.

A similar Sunday alcohol sales bill was introduced last year by Democratic state Sen. Gilda Jacobs of Huntington Woods. It has not advanced in the Senate.

To track the bills, see the Michigan Legislature's Web site.


Fan kicked out of Bengals stadium to step up criticism of general manager

Removal of spectator from publicly funded Cinergy Field 'raises serious free-speech concerns,' says constitutional law attorney. 12.04.98

Football team wants no signs at bill signing
'This is denying free speech and our constitutional right to protest,' says activist who is fighting proposed sales tax for Green Bay Packers' stadium. 05.10.00

Buffalo Bills bar fans' signs of frustration
Local official says NFL team, under lease agreement, has complete control over county-owned stadium during games and can set its own rules. 12.30.05

6th Circuit allows Indians fan to pursue free-speech claim
'It reaffirms the right of fans in baseball and football to heckle players, which we believe is protected by the First Amendment,' says attorney for fan arrested at game in 2001. 09.18.06

University of N.H. tries to tame hockey fans’ tongues
'A reminder to students before the hockey games that families are in the audience is consistent with both free speech and civility,' says school spokeswoman. 11.13.06

Icing free speech: A fan and the First Amendment
By Ken Paulson Sports leagues misguidedly try to stop Mark Weinberg from selling his book criticizing team owner near Chicago Blackhawks' stadium. 09.14.03

Fan profanity

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Saturday, January 24, 2009 | 20:33:08
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links