First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
Divided 5th Circuit panel opens door for nonsectarian school-board prayer

By The Associated Press
12.18.06

Editor’s note: On Feb. 9, 2007, the full 5th Circuit agreed to rehear the case. Oral arguments are scheduled for May 22.

NEW ORLEANS — A divided federal appeals court panel has issued a ruling that may allow the Tangipahoa Parish School Board to begin its meetings with a nonsectarian prayer, and opened up a new chapter in a long dispute between school officials and the American Civil Liberties Union.

The three-judge panel of the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Dec. 15 in Doe v. Tangipahoa Parish School Board that the school board should be treated like other elected bodies, which are allowed to invoke nonsectarian and non-proselytizing prayers at their meetings.

But the panel upheld a district judge's view that the Tangipahoa board's previous practice of prayer violated the constitutional ban on government promotion of religion. Since that ruling in February 2005, the school board has not opened its meetings with a devotional.

"In so holding, this opinion takes no position on whether another form of prayer is permissible at Board meetings," U.S. Judge Rhesa Barksdale wrote for the majority. "Instead, it holds only that prayers of the type included in the stipulations do not pass constitutional muster."

The panel sent the case back to U.S. Judge Helen G. Berrigan, who had barred the school board from opening its meetings with prayers. The appellate court told Berrigan to amend her injunction considering the new ruling.

The ACLU originally brought suit over prayers not just at board meetings, but at high school football games. That portion of the suit was settled in 2004 with prayers being dropped at games and other school events.

The case has become a hotly contested political issue in Louisiana. Shortly before Hurricane Katrina hit on Aug. 29, 2005, Gov. Kathleen Blanco weighed in with a friend-of-the-court brief urging the appeals court to uphold opening prayers. The governor argued that Berrigan overreached in banning the kickoff devotionals.

Blanco argued that school boards are not like schools, but are simply government bodies, like legislatures, where an opening prayer is permitted.

Berrigan ruled that school boards are closely identified with the schools they govern, and should be subject to the same rules.

On Dec. 16, the ACLU and school board officials were assessing the significance of the ruling, which was issued late on Dec. 15 by the New Orleans-based appellate court.

"If it is like it seems, you can pray, but only generally," said Sandra Bailey-Simmons, the school board president. "It looks like censorship."

She said the majority of people in Tangipahoa are Christians and want the board to be able to invoke Christianity at its meetings. She said she was interested in appealing the decision.

Likewise, Joe Cook, the executive director of the Louisiana branch of the ACLU, said the ACLU might seek a rehearing or appeal.

He said the panel "avoided dealing with the central issue of whether school boards in general" should be allowed to hold prayers. The ACLU has argued that school boards are not like legislative bodies because they are an extension of the school system they oversee.

"How can they do something that they don't allow anywhere else in the school system?" Cook said. "They're supposed to be role models for the students, teachers and administrators in the system."


Update
Divided 5th Circuit vacates ruling on La. school-board prayer
Majority finds plaintiffs lack standing to challenge practice, sends case back to lower court with instructions to dismiss. 07.26.07

Previous
5th Circuit studies prayer at school board meetings
During oral arguments, judges ask pointed questions of attorneys on both sides of Louisiana dispute. 02.09.06

Related

ACLU wants school officials jailed for flouting prayer ban

For fourth time in less than two months, group notifies federal judge that teachers, administrators in Louisiana parish have violated court settlement. 05.20.05

ACLU: Deal reached in student teacher's suit over school prayer
Cynthia Thompson sued Tangipahoa Parish School Board, Southeastern Louisiana University, saying she entered 'nightmare' of constant prayer, proselytizing in fourth-grade class. 10.04.06

ACLU sues La. school system over Bible distribution
Lawsuit, which is fifth filed against Tangipahoa Parish over religion in 13 years, claims middle school principal improperly allowed people to hand out Gideon Bibles to students. 05.18.07

Graduation prayer lands La. district in hot water — again
'I'm not aware of any school district that's been sued this many times for religious freedom,' state ACLU head says after Tangipahoa Parish is hit with 6th suit in 13 years. 06.10.07

Legislative prayer

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print


Last system update: Saturday, January 24, 2009 | 23:29:01
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

First Reports
Supreme Court
Experts
Columnists
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Sings™
Events
First Amendment
Schools

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links