First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
'Saving Private Ryan' not indecent, FCC rules

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON — ABC's television broadcast last Veterans Day of the Oscar-winning war movie "Saving Private Ryan," which contains graphic violence and profanity, did not violate indecency guidelines, regulators ruled.

The film contained "numerous expletives and other potentially offensive language generally as part of the soldiers' dialogue," the Federal Communications Commission said.

"In light of the overall context in which this material is presented, the commission determined it was not indecent or profane," the five-member FCC said in a unanimous decision in denying complaints over the movie.

"This film is a critically acclaimed artwork that tells a gritty story — one of bloody battles and supreme heroism," FCC chairman Michael Powell said in a statement yesterday. "The horror of war and the enormous personal sacrifice it draws on cannot be painted in airy pastels."

Some complaints also cited the movie's violence, but the FCC said its indecency and profanity guidelines were not applicable to violent programming.

A spokeswoman for ABC in New York declined comment.

Sixty-six ABC affiliates, covering nearly a third of the country, ultimately decided not to air Steven Spielberg's movie on Nov. 11 owing to their skittishness over whether the film would be deemed indecent — even though the FCC in 2002 had already ruled it was not.

ABC broadcast the film uncut in 2001 and 2002. The movie opens with a violent depiction of the D-Day invasion and includes profanity.

The indecency law bars nonsatellite radio and noncable television stations from airing between 6 a.m. and 10 p.m. indecent material such as references to sexual and excretory functions. Those are the hours when children are more likely to be watching television.

But not all sexual and excretory references or scenes are considered indecent. The FCC must consider context and its decisions are subjective interpretations of the law.

Powell said the FCC's ruling yesterday showed how the agency considers the context of the material before issuing an indecency ruling. ABC and its affiliates made "a responsible effort" to give viewers "full and wide disclosure" over what was to be shown and heard, allowing families to make well-informed decisions over whether to watch, Powell said.

The broadcast featured an introduction and a warning about the film's content by Republican Sen. John McCain of Arizona, who was a prisoner of war in Vietnam.

Among those filing complaints were members of the Tupelo, Miss.-based American Family Association, which on its Web site describes itself as standing "for traditional family values" and focusing on the influence of television and media on society.

There was no answer at a phone number posted on the association's Web site. According to the site, the group's supporters filed 16,000 complaints about the movie.

The FCC, in separate rulings, also denied indecency complaints filed by the Parents Television Council, a watchdog >group, against the NBC comedy "Will and Grace" and the Fox comedy "Arrested Development."

The Parents Television Council said yesterday it would also file an indecency complaint with the FCC over the Feb. 17 episode of the CBS crime drama "CSI: Crime Scene Investigation." The episode made references to "perverse and graphic" sexual acts, the group said.

TV stations pull plug on 'Saving Private Ryan,' cite fear of FCC
More than 20 ABC affiliates won't take part in Veterans Day airing of Oscar-winning movie, saying film's violence, language could draw sanctions from agency. 11.11.04


House again votes to hike indecency fines

Lawmakers overwhelmingly approve bill 389-38, rejecting criticism that stiffer penalties would stifle free speech, expression and further homogenize programming. 02.17.05

'Monday Night Football' intro not indecent, FCC rules
Terrell Owens-Nicollette Sheridan skit was racy, agency says, but didn't violate indecency standards. 03.15.05

FCC seeks $1.4 million for 'NYPD Blue' episode
Agency claims showing woman's bare buttocks in 2003 broadcast was indecent; ABC says finding is inconsistent with prior agency decisions, First Amendment. 01.28.08

Censorship in the name of decency?
By Gene Policinski As some CBS affiliates hesitate to air a 9/11 documentary because of firefighters' foul language, we must ask should we block free and open discussion because the reality of that day's events may offend some? 09.05.06

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Sunday, January 25, 2009 | 02:35:59
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links