First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
Watchdog group: Kids have easy access to violent video games

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON — A watchdog group warned yesterday that video games are featuring increased violence against women and called on retailers to do a better job of keeping such games out of the hands of children.

The video-game trade association called the report by the National Institute on Media and the Family "illogical and grotesquely unfair."

In its annual review of the video-game industry, the Minneapolis-based institute singled out several games, most notably "Grand Theft Auto: Vice City." In that game, players ramp up their score by having sex with a prostitute, and gain additional points by killing her. The game includes scenes in which blood splatters out of a woman's body as the player beats her to death.

Rep. Betty McCollum, D-Minn., said such games "are creating a culture of virtual victimizers."

The game is rated M for Mature audiences (over age 17), but children have no trouble buying it, said David Walsh, the institute's president and author of the report. The institute gave the industry an overall grade of F.

"Young children have no trouble getting these games," Walsh said.

Sen. Joseph Lieberman, D-Conn., who has spearheaded efforts to limit children's exposure to violence in the media, credited the industry for ceasing to market their adult games to children.

But he said parents and retailers need to do more to prevent children from getting the violent games. The most troubling trend, Lieberman said, is that "women are the new targets of choice in the most violent games."

He said it might be time for a new round of congressional hearings.

Doug Lowenstein, president of the video-game trade group, Interactive Digital Software Association, said the report's focus on violence against women was a distortion.

"They cite one or two games where they have issues," he said. "This is an industry where the average age is 28."

He pointed to a Federal Trade Commission study issued in 2000 that found adults were present for 82% of video-game purchases.

As for as the violence in "Grand Theft Auto," Lowenstein said, "I won't get into individual creative elements of these games. The games are properly rated... . You can't sanitize interests."

Dawn Berrie, a spokeswoman for Take-Two Interactive, which owns the manufacturer of Grand Theft Auto, said in a statement that "the company makes every effort to market its games responsibly, (and) target advertising and marketing only to adult consumers over the age of 17."

The report said only 70% of retailers have polices preventing children from buying or renting games rated M. That figure is slightly higher, 75%, for chain stores.

Hal Halpin, president of the Interactive Entertainment Merchants Association, a trade group for chain stores that sell video games, said the stores have improved in recent years.

"We're actively working to educate our own clerks at the store level as well as customers and parents," he said.

On the Net:
Entertainment Software Rating Board


Lieberman renews efforts on entertainment-marketing bill

Lawmaker sends letter asking Senate colleagues to support plan, as House introduces his measure to punish media companies for promoting adult material to minors. 06.22.01

FTC: Music industry still marketing adult fare to kids
But agency reports movie, video game companies have made 'commendable progress' in not targeting children with violent, sexually explicit advertising. 12.06.01

Minnesota lawmakers say 'game over' to kids' violent games
Senate passes measure that would make it illegal for children under 17 to rent or buy adult-rated video games. 05.10.03

Entertainment media again accused of exposing kids to violence
Some critics are calling for government intervention, say industry is 'hiding behind the cloak of the First Amendment'; but media executives say self-regulation is working. 10.30.03

Groups decry sex, violence in video games
National Institute on Media and the Family urges industry to better educate parents about ratings, asks retailers not to sell games with mature themes to younger teens. 11.28.04

Columbine lawsuits seek to blame the image and the game
If violent entertainment is as pernicious as some say, then why isn't every small town, city, and school in America afflicted with high levels of violence? 06.02.01

Pong revisited: Free speech and video games
By Ken Paulson Hitting a ball with a paddle didn’t involve plot, character, ideas — as today's games do. 10.21.01

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Sunday, January 25, 2009 | 05:05:58
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links