First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
Report: Government secrecy down slightly from record levels

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON — Federal officials unsealed more classified documents in 2005 but shrouded data elsewhere by claiming more legal privileges in court, a coalition of watchdog groups has reported.

The study by shows modest improvement from record 2004 levels in which Americans were kept in the dark about information the coalition says they should be able to access. Overall government secrecy remained high compared to previous years, it said.

Federal agencies spent $134 creating and storing new secrets for each $1 spent to declassify old secrets. That's down from the record $148 in 2004, but up from the $17-to-$1 ratio spent in 2000.

Overall, the number of pages declassified in 2005 was 29.5 million, up 1.1 million from the previous year, to post the first increase in five years. Still, the figure was significantly lower than the 75 million documents unsealed in 2000, the year before the Sept. 11 terror attacks.

The government stamped 14.2 million documents "top secret," "secret" or "confidential" at a cost of $7.7 billion, compared to a record 15.6 million documents sealed in 2004.

"Every administration wants to control information about its policies and practices, but the current administration has restricted access to information about our government and its policies at unprecedented levels," said Patrice McDermott, director of

"How can the public or even Congress make informed decisions under such circumstances?" she asked.

In the study, titled "Secrecy Report Card 2006," the watchdog coalition found greater assertions of executive power by the Bush administration, using the "state secrets" privilege successfully in court to keep information secret on national security grounds.

It invoked the privilege 22 times from 2001-July 2005, an average of four per year that is almost as high as the average in the previous 24 years. At the height of the Cold War, presidential administrations used the privilege just six times between 1953 and 1976.

The report also found that President Bush issued 132 signing statements claiming exceptions to 810 provisions of federal laws he had just signed, compared to 600 signing statements in the 211 years of U.S. history preceding 2000. The watchdog group said the statements, which an American Bar Association panel has said violate the Constitution, create public confusion.

Other findings:

  • Classified or "black" programs account for 17% of this year's Pentagon budget of $315.5 billion, down slightly from 18% in 2005.

  • The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court — which oversees requests for government surveillance of people within the United States — approved all 2,072 requests for secret surveillance orders, up 18% from the year before.

McDermott urged more public disclosure and accountability with closer oversight by Congress as well as passage of bills to strengthen the Freedom of Information Act.

Report finds increasing trend of government secrecy troubling director: Public, Congress should be concerned about president's use of state-secrets privilege, lack of disclosure. 09.04.07

Report: Government secrecy grows, costs more
Coalition finds big jump in secrets from 2003-04, but archives oversight director says numbers don't solely reflect overclassification, as some agencies now work 24/7. 09.06.05


Senators seek to declassify more prewar-intelligence info

Bipartisan group asks Public Interest Declassification Board to consider whether portions of Senate reports could be made public without harming national security. 09.20.06

Post-9/11 secrecy: pervasive and dangerous
By Paul K. McMasters With too closed a government, we court dysfunctional democracy, or government by hindsight, in which post-crisis panels struggle to explain what never should have happened. 09.11.05

Criminalizing speech to protect secrets
By Paul K. McMasters The specter of an 'official secrets act' rises again, casting a pall over free speech, free flow of information and government accountability. 08.13.06

Freedom of information overview

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Monday, February 9, 2009 | 23:24:47
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links