First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
Lawmaker pulls death-penalty art from Texas Capitol exhibit

By The Associated Press

AUSTIN, Texas — A state lawmaker removed two pieces of art from a Capitol exhibit organized by a group opposed to the death penalty because he said he found the images inappropriate and objectionable.

State Rep. Borris Miles, a Houston Democrat, took issue with a painting of a man hanging from a rope and an illustration of a man tied to an electric chair with the inscription "Doing God's Work."

"We should not prevent the display of art," Miles said on March 13. "But there have to be limits."

Miles said in an e-mail to his House colleagues that he encountered the images while walking through a hall of the Capitol Extension on March 12 with his children, ages 5 and 8.

"Capitol exhibits are supposed to serve a public purpose or be informational in nature. These pictures were hung with no accompanying text or explanation," Miles wrote.

The Texas Moratorium Network, which advocates a two-year moratorium on the death penalty, didn't violate any standards with the exhibit, said Scott Cobb, the group's president.

He said the purpose of the artwork, some of which was created by death-row inmates, was to call attention to the death penalty.

"Nobody has a right to take down what they don't like. (Miles) overreacted and should have gone through the proper channels" to remove the work, Cobb said.

Miles, who has talked with the State Preservation Board about his complaint, said a system should be put in place to screen exhibits.

The preservation board, caretaker of the Capitol, requires that exhibits in the Capitol serve a "public purpose" and have an elected official as a sponsor.

Spokeswoman Julie Fields said the preservation board does not "restrict or censor" exhibitions.

Miles delivered the pieces on March 13 to state Rep. Harold Dutton, another Houston Democrat, the sponsor of the exhibit.

Dutton questioned whether censoring objectionable artwork would defeat the purpose of allowing art displays. The moratorium group has agreed to Dutton's request to leave the pieces out of future displays.

"It doesn't bother me whether it's up or down," Dutton said.

Fields said she doesn't recall ever getting complaints about a Capitol display.

"This is a little overwhelming to us. We don't feel like it's our place to make decisions about what goes into a building or not," she said.


Students protest removal of anti-Bush artwork from campus exhibit

University of Wisconsin-Green Bay chancellor says piece, which includes image of president with gun pointed at his head, is inappropriate for school's gallery. 09.19.05

Fla. city agrees to display disputed religious paintings
'I don't look at it like they lost and I won, I think everybody won because this is the right thing to do,' says artist. 02.19.06

College cancels 'needlessly divisive' art exhibit
University of Southern Maine show featured paintings by inmate who killed a New Jersey state trooper in 1981 and has cast himself as a political prisoner. 09.11.06

To some, ‘obscene’ art not to be seen, heard
By Brian J. Buchanan First Amendment Center founder pores over history of attempts to regulate artistic expression. PODCAST VIDEO 11.10.06

Deep-fried American flag exhibit sparks censorship
'It's about what the community values,' says Tennessee museum director; art student says 'The Fat is in the Fire' is commentary on obesity in America. 11.20.06

Artists pull works after City Hall bans Mao-Washington print
Piece depicts communist dictator Mao Zedong next to George Washington. 02.24.07

Penn State sued over squelched terrorism art exhibit
'Portraits of Terror' focused on Arab-Palestinian attacks against Israel; university says it rescinded cancellation but grad student ignored offers to display work. 05.02.07

2 drawings booted from Texas arts-center show
Artist says she's surprised Lubbock officials barred images of breastfeeding mother, nude pregnant woman from Buddy Holly Center. 12.14.07

Arts & First Amendment horizon

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Tuesday, February 10, 2009 | 07:31:55
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links