First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
Feds ask group to pay almost $373,000 for records

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON — The Justice Department says a group that wants to see secret documents about the detention of people jailed after the Sept. 11 attacks first must pay nearly $373,000 to cover the cost of searching for the information.

And the advance payment won’t guarantee anything that’s found will be released.

Under the Freedom of Information Act, government agencies must provide the public with access to government documents, unless the information falls under certain exemptions. The first two hours of a search are free. Agencies then charge for searches, the rate dependent on the level of the employees who do the work.

People for the American Way Foundation, which sued for the records last year, accused the Justice Department of making the cost exceedingly high to deter its request.

“Unfortunately it’s part of a pattern of the Justice Department trying to foreclose access to this kind of information,” Elliot Mincberg, the group’s legal director, said yesterday.

Justice Department spokesman Charles Miller said that was not so. “The determination of FOIA costs is dependent upon the amount of research that is required,” Miller said.

Public interest and media groups can seek waivers to fees. People for the American Way, a civil rights and constitutional liberties group based in Washington, will request a waiver and will go to court if the request is denied, Mincberg said.

Journalism organizations and other public interest groups said the fee was unusually high.

“If that’s what it takes to track down secrecy in our court system, things are worse than I thought,” said Lucy Dalglish, executive director of the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press. “They think if they put a really big price on it, maybe the group will back off.”

The Justice Department, in a letter to Mincberg, said the search of all 93 U.S. attorneys offices probably would take a year. “We do not know at this time how many pages of records, if any, will be eventually released,” the letter said.

The estimate of $372,999 is a minimum, representing 13,314 ¼ hours of search time at $28 an hour, the letter said.

Much of the time would be spent looking through “thousands of case files,” the letter said. The U.S. attorney in southern Florida said it would take “hundreds of hours” to review files in that office alone, probably adding to the cost, the government said.

But Mincberg said there were relatively few cases that would fall under the request. “They ought to know when they are trying to block information about what are ordinarily open proceedings,” he said.

The lawsuit grew out of the government’s refusal to release records about the detention of Mohamed Kamel Bellahouel and others, which were sought initially in a request under the Freedom of Information Act. Records of habeas corpus cases have traditionally been open to the public, the suit said.

Bellahouel, a waiter from Algeria, was detained by the FBI after the Sept. 11 attacks. He came under scrutiny because he may have served meals at a South Florida restaurant to two of the Sept. 11 hijackers, Mohamed Atta and Marwan al-Shehhi, authorities have said.

Bellahouel was eventually released without being charged. The Supreme Court turned down his appeal to consider whether the Justice Department acted properly in secretly jailing him and keeping the proceedings under wraps. The case, M.K.B. v. Warden, was joined by more than 20 media companies and journalism organizations.

The lawsuit asks for records related to all government requests for sealed proceedings in the cases of people who challenged their detentions after the Sept. 11 attacks.

The group is willing to accept edited copies to protect national security and is not pushing for release of identities of the individuals, Mincberg said. The goal, the lawsuit says, is to determine how often the Justice Department asked judges to seal such records.


High court won't hear detainee secrecy case

Algerian waiter's attorneys had asked justices to rule whether lower courts were right to block info from press, public. 02.23.04

State asks group to pay $187,650 for access to Dean records
Judicial Watch attorney describes Vermont officials' request as 'preposterous.' 03.18.04

Alabama sheriff sets high price for records searches
Tuscaloosa County official institutes $38-per-hour charge for certain searches after judge orders him to release some crime reports. 04.06.05

Iowa agencies to charge for attorney review of public records
Decision by governor's office to institute fee comes after two large, unrelated requests for public e-mails from Des Moines Register. 05.08.08

What we can’t know hurts us
By Paul K. McMasters In the war on terrorism, too much public information is missing in action. 02.06.05

How to file an FOIA request

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Tuesday, February 10, 2009 | 10:27:17
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links