overviewfrequently asked questionscases & resources
Attorney general orders review of state-secrets claims

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON — The new U.S. attorney general, Eric Holder, has ordered a review of all claims of state secrets, which were used under President George W. Bush to shield controversial anti-terrorism programs from lawsuits.

The so-called state-secrets privilege was invoked by the previous administration to stymie a lawsuit challenging the government’s warrantless-wiretapping program.

“The attorney general has directed that senior Justice Department officials review all assertions of the state-secrets privilege to ensure that (it) is being invoked only in legally appropriate situations,” Justice Department spokesman Matt Miller said yesterday.

“It’s vital that we protect information that if released could jeopardize national security, but the Justice Department will ensure the privilege is not invoked to hide from the American people information about their government’s actions that they have a right to know,” said Miller.

Even as officials promised a thorough review, government lawyers continued to invoke the state-secrets privilege yesterday in a case before the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco. That case involves a lawsuit over the CIA’s extraordinary rendition program.

Under that program, U.S. operatives seized foreign suspects and handed them over to other countries for questioning.

Some former prisoners subjected to the process contend they were tortured. Proving that in court has been difficult, as evidence they have sought to corroborate their claims has been protected by the president’s state-secrets privilege.

The American Civil Liberties Union has been urging the Obama administration to drop its state-secrets claim.

ACLU executive director Anthony Romero criticized the new administration’s handling of the San Francisco case by continuing the legal arguments of the prior administration.

“Candidate Obama ran on a platform that would reform the abuse of state secrets, but President Obama’s Justice Department has disappointingly reneged on that important civil liberties issue,” Romero said in a statement.


Federal judge faults Bush administration for excessive secrecy (news)
Ruling declares that ‘because we say so’ isn’t a good enough reason to withhold records under Freedom of Information Act. 09.06.07

Bush to sign warrantless-wiretapping overhaul (news)
Bill, which Senate passed and sent to White House, is victory for president, as it grants immunity to telecom companies as he demanded and ends almost a year of political wrangling. 07.09.08

Obama orders rollback of government secrecy (news)
On first full day of office, new president moves to open presidential records, change how agencies interpret freedom-of-information law, limit lobbying. 01.22.09

ACLU asks Obama to release Bush-era memos (news)
Documents are wish list for civil rights groups, members of Congress seeking more information about legal reasoning that underpinned last administration's secret programs. 01.30.09

Obama's First Amendment record shows varied views (analysis)
By Courtney Holliday Democratic candidate advocates strongly for open government; has led efforts against lobbying, attacked indecency. 09.29.08

Too much secrecy is also a threat (commentary)
By Gene Policinski Keeping some government information under wraps may protect us in some ways, but it also leaves us vulnerable to hidden problems we should know about. 09.09.07

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

print this   Print

Last system update: Tuesday, February 10, 2009 | 20:10:33
Freedom of Information issues >
Open records
Open meetings
National FOI Day
Post-9/11 info access
How to file an FOIA request