First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
print this   Print

Nation's first statewide voucher program defeated at Utah polls

By The Associated Press

SALT LAKE CITY — Utah voters yesterday killed the nation’s first statewide school voucher program that promised tax dollars for private tuition, no matter how much a family earned or whether kids were in bad schools.

It was the first voucher election in the U.S. since 2000, when voters in Michigan and California rejected efforts to subsidize private schools.

Utah, with a conservative electorate, a Republican governor and a GOP-controlled Legislature, was seen nationally as a key test of voter sentiment for vouchers. But opponents, with millions of dollars from a national teachers union, persuaded residents to say no.

With 95% of 2,237 precincts reporting, 62% of voters cast ballots against the program.

“The problem of voucher supporters is that they never really figured out what Utah voters would support in advance of passing legislation,” said Brigham Young University political scientist Quin Monson.

“They never really anticipated it would go to the ballot,” he said, adding that lawmakers were “shooting a little too high.”

Pre-election public opinion polls indicated widespread opposition to vouchers, especially in rural areas where often there are no private schools for hundreds of miles.

Utah’s referendum on vouchers was the first in the country since 2000, when voucher proposals were voted down in Michigan and California. There have been 10 state referendums on various voucher programs since 1972, according to the National School Boards Association. Each time vouchers or tuition tax credits were voted down by an average of 68.6%. California, Michigan and Colorado voters defeated voucher proposals twice.

Voucher critics argued the state shouldn’t spend money on private schools when Utah has the nation’s largest class sizes and spends less per student than any other state. Voucher proponents contended the program would reduce classes in public schools, give parents a choice of which school their child goes to that’s not dictated by where they can afford to live, and improve public schools through competition.

“It’s a big relief, and it’s an expression of support for Utah’s schools,” said Utah Education Association President Kim Campbell, a voucher opponent.

Both sides spent millions in recent months on TV ads. Opposition to vouchers was primarily funded by teachers unions, with the National Education Association spending nearly $3.2 million on the campaign against vouchers. founder and CEO Patrick Byrne and his family were the primary financiers behind the pro-voucher commercials, donating more than $2.7 million of the $3.8 million raised by Parents for Choice in Education. Out-of-state conservative think tanks donated much of the rest.

Doug Holmes, chairman of Parents for Choice in Education, said opponents used fear to kill vouchers. Prize-winning teachers surrounded by kids appeared in TV ads warning that the program was flawed and a threat to public schools.

“Serious people who evaluated the policy — the governor, the Legislature, the business community, etc. — all support this,” Holmes said.

Unions “come in with misinformation and scare tactics and scare people into supporting the status quo even though the status quo is not doing a great job,” he said.

People on both sides of the issue said the referendum’s outcome would influence how vouchers play out in other states.

Voucher programs exist in various forms in about a dozen states. Most are limited programs, targeted at low-income students in poorly performing districts or at special needs students. Many conservative lawmakers would like to see those voucher programs expanded.

Utah is one of the nation’s most conservative states and was targeted by national voucher advocates as a state likely to be receptive to a voucher program. Voucher groups, primarily funded by the heirs to the Wal-Mart fortune and the founder of Amway, spent hundreds of thousands of dollars helping to elect pro-voucher candidates to the Utah Legislature. Support for vouchers got popular Republican Gov. Jon Huntsman through the Republican Party’s caucus system and on the ballot.

Huntsman signed the voucher bill into law but wouldn’t tell people how to vote.

Many conservatives said Huntsman was bowing to public pressure after surveys repeatedly showed most voters didn’t want vouchers. He appeared at an Oct. 17 news conference that was turned into a pro-voucher ad.

Spokeswoman Lisa Roskelley did not return a message seeking comment on the election result.

Byrne, who bankrolled most of the pro-voucher campaign, expressed disappointment with the governor as the votes were counted last night.

“Once he saw the polls on this referendum he’s been pretty much missing in action,” Byrne told KUTV.

Fall election will decide fate of Utah vouchers
State high court rules second voucher statute wouldn't be enough to start program if voters kill original measure Nov. 6. 06.12.07


California, Michigan voucher plans flunk at ballot box

Teachers unions, governors lead campaigns against measures to offer state money for private school education. 11.08.00

House committee nixes Bush's school voucher plan

Legislators say measure’s removal will boost chances for wider support for bill. 05.03.01

Fla. high court strikes down school-voucher system
Justices sidestep church-state separation issue, ruling instead program violates state constitution's requirement of uniform system of free public schools. 01.05.06

Ariz. judge upholds school-voucher programs
Court finds grants to parents of disabled, foster children aren't appropriations of state money for religious worship or instruction. 06.18.07

Fla. judge won't strike voucher amendments from ballot
Teachers union president says group will campaign against proposals, which would let students attend religious, other private schools at taxpayer expense, while it appeals ruling. 08.05.08

Fla. high court strips voucher amendments from ballot
Justices overturn lower court ruling that would have let voters consider proposals to allow students to attend religious, other private schools at taxpayer expense. 09.05.08


News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

Last system update: Monday, August 3, 2009 | 22:46:00
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links