Text Only
Search

 
Imposing Sanctions Is Easy, Making Them Work Is Harder


10 March 2008
Besheer report - Download (MP3) audio clip
Besheer report - Listen (MP3) audio clip
Sanctions: Process report / Broadband - Download (WM) video clip
Sanctions: Process report / Broadband - Watch (WM) video clip
Sanctions: Process report / Dialup - Download (WM) video clip
Sanctions: Process report / Dialup - Watch (WM) video clip

For decades, sanctions have been used as a diplomatic tool to pressure governments to change their bad behavior. VOA's Margaret Besheer takes a look at how sanctions are imposed and enforced.

When a country feels it is necessary to impose sanctions on another government, the head of state or the national legislature has the authority to impose punitive measures.

But Professor Tom Weiss of the City University of New York says unilateral sanctions are difficult to enforce.

"Rarely does a single country have enough leverage to make sanctions work because there are always alternative sources of supply," said Weiss. "And there are numerous ways for a country that is sanctioned to break the sanctions."

Since few countries have the influence necessary to enforce effective sanctions on their own, they usually go through the United Nations Security Council in the hopes of imposing comprehensive sanctions that have the broad support of member states.

U.N. Security Council
U.N. Security Council
The Security Council has used its power to impose sanctions when international peace has been threatened and diplomatic efforts have failed. In the last few years, the trend has been toward targeted or so-called "smart" sanctions. They include economic and trade sanctions, arms embargoes, travel bans and financial measures, such as freezing assets.

Gary Hufbauer of the Peterson Institute for International Economics says smart sanctions are directed at regimes and tend to spare suffering within the general population.

"If you can somehow deprive the elite of their bank accounts, of their schools in Switzerland, their travels and so forth, at least you don't penalize ordinary people," said Hufbauer. "So the plus of that is that you don't have the bad side of sanctions, which is widespread ill-health or malnourishment, especially of older people and children, which causes a lot of backlash."

Just this month [March 2008], the Security Council used its mandate to impose targeted sanctions against the Iranian government for its controversial nuclear activities, which some nations believe is a cover for a secret nuclear weapons program. Professor Weiss says this latest round of sanctions against Iran is likely to only have a symbolic impact.

"The regime [in Iran] is clearly not keen to have these sanctions," he said. They clearly want to be a member of the international community of states and they spent a lot of diplomatic effort to make sure these sanctions did not come about. Not because it is going to have a real impact, in terms of day-to-day economics, but it is going to have a large, symbolic impact."

Once the Security Council imposes sanctions, such as the ones against Iran, there are several specialized U.N. agencies and other intergovernmental organizations that play a role in their monitoring, implementation and compliance.

One of the most important is Interpol -- the world's largest international police organization. More than 180 countries belong to Interpol, and the organization's highly trained personnel help enforce arms embargoes, travel bans and financial sanctions. International customs and aviation authorities are also key to enforcement.

Regional organizations such as the European Union, the Arab League and the Organization of American States have also played important roles in sanctions enforcement.

But despite international efforts to enforce sanctions, many experts say they cannot be used on their own and need to be part of a broader equation in order to be effective.

 

emailme.gif E-mail This Article
printerfriendly.gif Print Version

  Related Stories
Do Sanctions Work?
Experts: Sanctions Partially Successful as Diplomatic Tool
Iran Condemns New UN Sanctions
UN Security Council Imposes New Sanctions Against Iran
 
  Top Story
Reported NATO Airstrike Kills Scores in Northern Afghanistan

  More Stories
Burmese Court Agrees to Aung San Suu Kyi Appeal
Armed Police Dispatched Following New Urumqi Demonstrations  Audio Clip Available
S. Korea, U.S. Concerned By North Korean Uranium Announcement  Audio Clip Available
Family, Friends Pay Final Tribute to Michael Jackson  Audio Clip Available
Los Angeles-Area Fire Declared Arson, Homicide Probe Launched
Rescue Efforts Continue After Indonesia Earthquake  Audio Clip Available
Gates: Afghan War 'Not Slipping Through' Obama's Fingers  Audio Clip Available
US Cuts Some Aid to Honduras  Audio Clip Available
Path Is Unclear for Fatah's New Leaders  Video clip available
Gabon Imposes Curfew After Violence Over Election Win by Son of Late President
Biden Says US Economic Stimulus Plan is Working  Video clip available
Late US Senator's Memoir Talks of Personal, Public Tragedies