First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
print this   Print

Mo. teen files free-speech suit in photo flap

By The Associated Press

EUREKA, Mo. — A high school sophomore and his father have filed a federal lawsuit against suburban St. Louis school officials after the student was disciplined for taking photos of his teacher and posting them online.

The case highlights the emerging dilemma that the Internet poses for schools, with questions about how, or if, their disciplinary practices extend beyond schoolhouse walls.

The suit alleges that officials at Lafayette High School violated Logan Glover's constitutional rights to free speech and free expression. However, school district officials say the case is about controlling classroom behavior, not about the student's right to communicate online.

The lawsuit was filed Dec. 11 in U.S. District Court in St. Louis. It also names the boy's father, Jerome Glover, as a plaintiff. The defendants named in the suit are Lafayette Principal John Shaughnessy and two associate principals, Kirti Mehrotra and Jodi Davidson.

According to an affidavit by Shaughnessy, Glover and two classmates disrupted a language-arts class on Nov. 20 when they surreptitiously took the pictures of teacher Jessica Hauser.

The photos show the teacher working at her desk with students nearby. She is handling paperwork as she speaks with two boys. In one picture, a boy gives a thumbs-up to the camera while the teacher is looking away.

After school that day at his home, Glover posted the pictures on his private Facebook page. He did not post captions with the photographs, or identify anyone in them, the lawsuit states.

The suit claims Glover removed the photos on Dec. 6, when school officials confronted him about them. Glover got a three-day, out-of-school suspension and was permanently removed from Hauser's classroom. The other boys involved each got three days of in-school suspension. They are not parties to the suit.

"The taking of photographs and posting them on the Internet is not necessarily wrong," said Rockwood Superintendent Craig Larson. "It's the disruption that this caused that prompted us to act."

He said he thought there were two disruptions, sending students to the teacher's desk and taking pictures without her knowledge, and a later disruption when students started talking about the matter and showing the teacher the pictures.

Mark Sableman, a First Amendment attorney with Thompson Coburn, filed the suit on the Glovers' behalf. He said the photographs were taken during a free-time period and did not disrupt instruction.

"The Glovers believe that the school district took action against Logan because it did not like having the photos posted on Facebook," Sableman told the St. Louis Post-Dispatch in a Dec. 13 e-mail. "The First Amendment and prior cases are clear that school officials do not have the right to discipline students for content they post on the Internet outside of school."

Larson said the incident upset the teacher. "She didn't know the intent of the pictures," Larson said. "She wondered, 'Why did you do this? What are you trying to do to me by posting these images?'"

Hauser's class included a teacher from the Special School District who worked with Glover. According to the suit, the school does not have a substitute class that meets Glover's special needs.

Larson said the district would find a suitable class for the student.


High court limits student speech in 'Bong Hits 4 Jesus' case

Schools may prohibit student expression that can be interpreted as advocating drug use, Chief Justice John Roberts writes. 06.25.07

Facebook photos sting Minn. high school students

Some stage walkout at school to protest punishment of students seen partying on social-networking pages. 01.11.08

Ind. teens punished for racy MySpace photos sue high school
ACLU, which filed suit, says administrators violated two girls' free speech by banning them from extracurricular activities for posting sexually suggestive photos during their summer vacation. 11.03.09

For high school students, free speech is no joke
By Charles C. Haynes Narrowly drawn as Supreme Court justices tried to make 'Bong Hits 4 Jesus' ruling, don’t be surprised when many school officials and judges use it to find new grounds for censoring students. 07.08.07

5th Circuit extends limits on student speech
By Douglas Lee Panel makes several curious twists and turns to reach conclusion that its decision 'follow(s) the lead' of recent Supreme Court ruling. 11.27.07

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

Last system update: Tuesday, November 3, 2009 | 02:24:38
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links