First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
print this   Print

Nixing 'Ave Maria' at graduation prompts lawsuit

By The Associated Press
07.18.06

EVERETT, Wash. — The Everett school superintendent has been served with papers concerning a federal First Amendment lawsuit filed by a former student who says her rights were violated when a wind ensemble was stopped from playing "Ave Maria" at graduation.

The lawsuit filed by Kathryn Nurre, 18, marks the second time this year the Everett School District has been taken to court over free-speech issues.

"The way these two lawsuits are coming is different from anything that I've experienced," said schools chief Carol Whitehead, who has been superintendent in Everett since 2000 and held similar jobs at other districts previously.

Nurre and other senior members of the Henry M. Jackson High School wind ensemble selected an instrumental version of "Ave Maria" to play at commencement last month. School officials felt it was too religious for the school-sanctioned event. The song derives its name from a Catholic prayer.

"It's a difficult piece to play, and our wind ensemble could play it really well. ... Religion didn't even come into our minds at all," Nurre said.

Nurre, who played alto saxophone in the wind ensemble, said "Ave Maria" had been played at a winter concert without dispute.

But commencement is special, the superintendent said; as the pinnacle of a high school student's education, it's "quasi mandatory."

"It's different from an evening concert where they can choose to attend or not, and not just the students but the audience as well," Whitehead said.

Meanwhile, a trial date has been scheduled for spring in a case involving two Everett High School graduates and former editors of the student newspaper, The Kodak. Claire Lueneburg and Sara Eccleston sued the district, alleging violation of free speech and press freedom after administrators requested prior review of each issue.

Whitehead would not comment on the specifics of either case but said her decisions were based on legal advice.

"I don't make decisions based on personal philosophy. I make decisions based on what I agreed to do here," she said.

Lawyers for Nurre say things went too far last month when the superintendent vetoed the students' selection of German composer Franz Biebl's "Ave Maria" — Latin for "Hail Mary" — even though there was no plan to include its liturgical lyrics.

"You've got to be kidding me. Playing an instrumental is endorsing religion? ... People aren't stupid. They know schools aren't endorsing religion," said John Whitehead, president and founder of the Virginia-based Rutherford Institute.

The nonprofit conservative legal organization specializes in religious rights cases and is working on Nurre's behalf.

Nurre and her team of lawyers argue there was nothing proselytizing about the instrumental piece.

"I've seen these cases across the country ... where people with any kind of religious ideas are afraid to speak up anymore," John Whitehead said. "I don't think we want to make our schools into little enclaves of fear and chilled speech."

Lawyers specializing in school issues say the superintendent will likely have a good legal argument.

"The school district is responsible for the content on the program. Just as a district could censor a valedictorian speech, it also can censor religious music," said Richard Fossey, who now teaches education law at the University of Houston's school of education.

Both the "Ave Maria" and Kodak cases have drawn national attention, with reaction spilling into the Internet realm.

Bloggers have called Superintendent Whitehead "afraid of her own shadow." Criticism also has come from parents and some staff, though others support her.

"Everyone has a right to their opinion," she said.


Update
Wash. district's ban on 'Ave Maria' at graduation upheld
By Lydia Hailman King Federal judge finds school barred song to keep graduation nonreligious, not to denigrate a particular religion. 10.12.07

Related

Student editors challenge prior review of newspaper

Washington teens sue, arguing that since 1989, Kodak has served as public forum for Everett High students, with no content oversight by school administrators. 12.16.05

3rd Circuit lets suit proceed on religious music in school

By Melanie Bengtson Parent challenges N.J. district policy restricting performances of religious music. 10.12.06

Girl gets green light to sing religious tune at school talent show
Federal judge in Trenton, N.J., finds song 'Awesome God' is 'private speech' by a student, not message conveyed by school. 12.13.06

Graduation ceremonies

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.



Last system update: Monday, February 8, 2010 | 16:12:07
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
Columnists
Experts
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Sings™
Events
First Amendment
Schools

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links