First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
print this   Print

College cancels 'needlessly divisive' art exhibit

By The Associated Press

PORTLAND, Maine — The University of Southern Maine has canceled an art exhibit showcasing the paintings by a prison inmate who killed a New Jersey state trooper 25 years ago and has cast himself as a political prisoner.

The exhibit had drawn outrage from police agencies that said it painted an unfair picture of artist Thomas Manning, who is serving 80 years in prison for the 1981 killing of Trooper Philip Lamonaco after a traffic stop.

USM President Richard Pattenaude said the exhibit was designed to spark discussion about political dissent in society, but had become overshadowed by Manning's background and criminal history. The exhibit, he said, had become "misunderstood and needlessly divisive."

"What was to be a forum has become a battleground," Pattenaude said.

The exhibit, which opened on Sept. 1, was taken down on Sept. 8. A symposium to discuss political prisoners and political dissent is to go on as planned in October.

Manning, a former Portland resident, was part of a group of political radicals that robbed banks and bombed buildings in the 1970s and early 1980s to protest what they alleged was racism and U.S. imperialism. Organizers said the exhibit — titled "Can't Jail the Spirit: Art by Political Prisoner Tom Manning and Others" — was intended to spark debate.

But the event drew criticism from law enforcement groups.

George Loder, vice president of the Maine State Troopers Association, said police felt that the exhibit glossed over Manning's violent history. Loder said he was happy with the university's decision.

"Don't say he's a political activist when in fact he's a terrorist," Loder said.

At Pattenaude's press conference announcing the end of the exhibit, several students and exhibit organizers said they felt that the university was censoring free speech.

Jonah Fertig, an organizer with the Victory Gardens Project, a group that supports what it views as political prisoners, held up a sign reading, "USM Suppressing Free Speech." He says the university is allowing itself to be controlled.

"It seems to me that we are entering into a police state and censorship of free speech," Fertig said.


Student sues over removal of nude photos from campus exhibit

Blake Dews claims officials at Alabama university violated his free-expression rights by pulling three images depicting male nudity from his class assignment. 11.01.05

Justices won't intervene in art flap from Kan. university

10th Circuit earlier rejected argument from Washburn professor, student who said school's display of sculpture — which they contend is anti-Catholic — violated their religious freedom. 03.07.06

Art students plan to sue NYC, college over closed exhibit
Civil rights attorney Norman Siegel criticizes his alma mater, saying Brooklyn College 'aided and abetted censorship.' 05.09.06

Deep-fried American flag exhibit sparks censorship
'It's about what the community values,' says Tennessee museum director; art student says 'The Fat is in the Fire' is commentary on obesity in America. 11.20.06

Lawmaker pulls death-penalty art from Texas Capitol exhibit
'We should not prevent the display of art,' says Houston Democrat. 'But there have to be limits.' 03.15.07

NYCLU questions removal of Stalin banner
Group asks if Department of Buildings removed banner because of city regulations or because of Ukrainian association's complaints. 11.18.08

Art controversies

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

Last system update: Monday, February 8, 2010 | 16:59:43
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links