First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
print this   Print

2nd Circuit: School can punish teen for online criticism

By The Associated Press
05.30.08

Editor’s note: The Associated Press reported that Principal Karissa Niehoff was disciplined over accusations that she breached Avery Doninger’s privacy. In an e-mail response to a Wisconsin man criticizing her discipline of Doninger, Niehoff disclosed information about the student. In early June, Niefhoff was suspended without pay for two days and ordered to attend workshops or training sessions on federal student-privacy law.

NEW YORK — A federal appeals court ruled yesterday that a high school was within its rights to punish a student for writing critical comments about school administrators on the Internet.

The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said Lewis Mills High School in Burlington, Conn., has a responsibility like any school to teach students the boundaries of socially appropriate behavior.

"Vulgar or offensive speech — speech that an adult making a political point might have a constitutional right to employ — may legitimately give rise to disciplinary action by a school," the unanimous three-judge panel ruled in Doninger v. Niehoff.

Avery Doninger was disciplined after she used derogatory language to describe the administrators in a blog entry she made outside of school in April 2007.

Doninger's mother filed a lawsuit against the school, claiming her daughter's free-speech rights had been compromised. A federal judge ruled that the school acted appropriately in disqualifying her from running for senior class secretary.

The 2nd Circuit upheld the lower court’s ruling, finding there was no Supreme Court precedent to rely on in a case in which the expression does not occur on school grounds or at a school-sponsored event.

"We have determined, however, that a student may be disciplined for expressive conduct, even conduct occurring off school grounds, when this conduct 'would foreseeably create a risk of substantial disruption within the school environment,' or at least when it was similarly foreseeable that the off-campus expression might also reach campus," the appeals court wrote.

In her posting, Doninger encouraged others to contact the administration, something the appeals court said "was not only plainly offensive, but also potentially disruptive" of efforts to resolve a controversy at the school that prompted Avery to write the blog.

Doninger's attorney, Jon L. Schoenhorn, did not return a telephone message for comment for this story.


Update
Judge rejects student's blog claim, allows T-shirt issue to proceed
By David L. Hudson Jr. Federal judge hands Connecticut school officials a victory, but trial will proceed on student Avery Doninger's censorship claim. 01.20.09

Previous
2nd Circuit considers appeal from teen disciplined for blog post
Lawyer for Connecticut teen argues that what students write on the Internet shouldn't give schools more cause to regulate off-campus speech. 03.06.08

Related

Univ. of Del. student's Web page is protected speech

Federal magistrate sides with Maciej Murakowski, finding content was 'alleged attempt at humor' and not a true threat. 09.08.08

Student says he was booted from honor society for Facebook page

Page created by Alex Fuentes became popular venue for student criticism of Wesley Chapel (Fla.) High School. 02.04.10

Did student-speech rights go up in smoke?
By David L. Hudson Jr. Court's ruling in 'Bong Hits' case limits student speech, but it wasn't a complete disaster. 06.27.07

For high school students, free speech is no joke
By Charles C. Haynes Narrowly drawn as Supreme Court justices tried to make 'Bong Hits 4 Jesus' ruling, don’t be surprised when many school officials and judges use it to find new grounds for censoring students. 07.08.07

We’re strangling high school free speech, press
By Gene Policinski Between adverse court rulings and antagonistic school officials, students are learning that free expression is not valued. 08.12.07

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.



Last system update: Monday, February 8, 2010 | 10:39:53
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
Columnists
Experts
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Sings™
Events
First Amendment
Schools

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links