First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
print this   Print

Buffalo Bills bar fans' signs of frustration

By The Associated Press

BUFFALO, N.Y. — A frustrated Buffalo Bills fan knows how fast the security detail can move when it sees signs of woe at Ralph Wilson Stadium.

Motivated by the failure of his Bills, season-ticket holder Mike Allenbaugh carried a sign of protest to the final home game. But security forces took it away shortly before kickoff Dec. 17.

Allenbaugh thought he was obeying the rules, and after checking the team's stadium policy, came up with a sign that read: "firE coacheS dumP maNagement" — capital letters aligned to spell out ESPN. Fans do such things in hopes of getting themselves and their message on TV.

Allenbaugh says the security staff threatened to have him ejected before taking his sign, and that really annoys him.

"It's just ridiculous," he said this week. "I can go in there and say, 'Go Bills.' Why can't I say, 'I don't like you as a manager?'"

Allenbaugh wasn't alone. He was one of several fans whose letters published last weekend in The Buffalo News accused the Bills of stifling free speech. They saw security officials confiscate negative signs, T-shirts, and even paper bags some fans wore over their heads during Buffalo's 28-17 loss to Denver.

"Just because the management and coaching is awful, where do they get off violating our First Amendment right to freedom of speech?" Allenbaugh wrote.

The Bills did not return several messages left by the Associated Press.

The team's stadium policy posted on its Web site reads in part: "Banners and signs are permitted generally, but any such item deemed by management to be dangerous, inappropriate, or which obstructs the view for other guests will be removed. Flags or banners that are commercial or offensive in nature or attached to poles are prohibited."

Buffalo (5-10), coming off a 37-27 win at Cincinnati, closes the season on the road on New Year's Day against the New York Jets.

Ralph Wilson Stadium is owned by Erie County and leased to the team.

County Executive Joel Giambra said the team, under the lease agreement, has complete control over the stadium during a game and can set its own rules.

Allenbaugh's sign was directed at Tom Donahoe, team president, and the Mike Mularkey-led coaching staff, blamed by many for the Bills missing the playoffs for the sixth-straight year.

"The one part that they get you is 'anything deemed by management to be inappropriate,' and obviously, this was inappropriate to them," Allenbaugh said.


Fan kicked out of Bengals stadium to step up criticism of general manager

Removal of spectator from publicly funded Cinergy Field 'raises serious free-speech concerns,' says constitutional law attorney. 12.04.98

Football team wants no signs at bill signing

'This is denying free speech and our constitutional right to protest,' says activist who is fighting proposed sales tax for Green Bay Packers' stadium. 05.10.00

Ole Miss can ban Confederate flags at games, federal appeals panel says
'It is ironic that burning a flag is called free speech, but waving it is not,' says lawyer for white supremacist group. 08.21.00

9th Circuit: Cow Palace wrongly limits protesters' speech
Animal-rights activist had claimed small 'free-expression zones' set hundreds of feet from entrance to state-run arena stymied protests of circuses, rodeos. 10.20.04

Mich. bill aims to give sports fans more rights to cheer, jeer
Taxpayer-supported stadiums couldn't confiscate signs unless they block other fans' view, contain profanity or pose safety hazard. 09.13.06

Baseball fan settles 'God Bless America' suit
Bradford Campeau-Laurion had claimed police officer kicked him out of Yankee Stadium because he left his seat during patriotic tune. 07.08.09

Icing free speech: A fan and the First Amendment
By Ken Paulson Sports leagues misguidedly try to stop Mark Weinberg from selling his book criticizing team owner near Chicago Blackhawks' stadium. 09.14.03

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

Last system update: Monday, February 8, 2010 | 21:46:20
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links