First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
print this   Print

Divided 5th Circuit vacates ruling on La. school-board prayer

By The Associated Press

NEW ORLEANS — The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals yesterday vacated a lower court ruling against the Tangipahoa Parish School Board over prayers at board meetings, saying the plaintiffs didn't show they had standing to file the suit.

The appeals court, in an 8-7 split decision, also sent the case back to the lower court with instructions to dismiss the case brought by the American Civil Liberties Union on behalf of two public school students and their father.

Ron Wilson, an attorney who represented the plaintiffs, said the appeals court ruling means "the case is basically over."

Writing for the majority in Doe v. Tangipahoa Parish School Board, Chief Judge Edith Jones found that the court record had no evidence that the plaintiffs actually were exposed to the meeting invocations to claim a harm under the First Amendment's establishment clause.

Although standing had not been an issue, attorneys for the school board raised the issue in their brief to the appeals court.

"It is not this court's fault that the connection between their attendance and allegedly unconstitutional activity is not made in the record," the majority said.

"Without the requisite specifics, this court would be speculating upon the facts. This is something we cannot do, particularly in the standing context, where the facts must be proven, not merely asserted or inferred. ... To find lack of standing at this late stage no doubt poses an inconvenience for the parties. On the other hand, it spares this court from issuing a largely hypothetically-based ruling on issues of broad importance to deliberative public bodies in this circuit and beyond."

Schools Superintendent Mark Kolwe, in a statement, said he was "very pleased with the outcome" but declined further comment.

Kolwe said the board would meet with its attorneys Aug. 7 to discuss the impact of the ruling and to get advice on how to proceed with regard to prayer at board meetings in the future.

Wilson said he believed the 5th Circuit "used a weak argument on standing" to sidestep the constitutional issue.

"I think the court was looking for a reason not to decide this issue. That's unfortunate," he said.

"We wanted the court to make a decision as to whether or not prayer at school-board meetings, invocations at school-board meetings, were unconstitutional. The court completely avoided that issue. If you can't go to a court to get a determination on the issues, where can you go? I'm disappointed. Win, lose or draw, you want a determination on the merits."

Judge Fortunato P. Benavides disagreed with the majority's opinion that there was no proof in the record that the family was ever exposed to, and thus injured by, a prayer offered at a school-board meeting.

"The Does plainly alleged that they had attended board meetings and that they had witnessed the invocations offered there, and the pretrial order reveals that the board conceded this fact," Benavides said. "Yet the majority sidesteps this record evidence, choosing instead to redraw the parameters of this dispute and assert that standing is now lacking. I disagree."

He said to dismiss the case now for lack of standing "creates a contested fact question where the parties and the district judge agreed there was not one."

Benavides added, "The record bears out that the Does attended School Board meetings at which payers were offered. That exposure gave them standing to bring this suit then, and it gives them standing to maintain it now. They are entitled to a decision on the merits, and we should give them one."

The appeals court judges heard the case en banc in May after a three-judge panel provided a divided decision in the dispute for which both sides wanted clarity.

The ACLU sued the school board in October 2003. Another lawsuit over prayer at a Tangipahoa Parish high school graduation ceremony is pending at the district level.

U.S. District Judge Ginger Berrigan previously found that sectarian prayers at school-board meetings are unconstitutional.

La. school board revises policy on pre-meeting prayers
Attorney for Tangipahoa officials says changes aren't result of ACLU lawsuit challenging guidelines. 04.16.09

Divided 5th Circuit panel opens door for nonsectarian school-board prayer
Majority upholds district judge's view that Tangipahoa, La., board's previous practice of prayer violated First Amendment ban on government promotion of religion. 12.18.06


ACLU: Deal reached in student teacher's suit over school prayer

Cynthia Thompson sued Tangipahoa Parish School Board, Southeastern Louisiana University, saying she entered 'nightmare' of constant prayer, proselytizing in fourth-grade class. 10.04.06

ACLU sues La. school system over Bible distribution

Lawsuit, which is fifth filed against Tangipahoa Parish over religion in 13 years, claims middle school principal improperly allowed people to hand out Gideon Bibles to students. 05.18.07

Graduation prayer lands La. district in hot water — again
'I'm not aware of any school district that's been sued this many times for religious freedom,' state ACLU head says after Tangipahoa Parish is hit with 6th suit in 13 years. 06.10.07

La. board agrees teacher-led prayer was unconstitutional
Federal judge had given Tangipahoa school board deadline to concede that teacher-led graduation prayer was out of bounds. 06.29.08

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

Last system update: Monday, February 8, 2010 | 21:08:14
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Singsā„¢
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links