First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
print this   Print

Democrats' report: White House interferes with climate science

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON — The White House has systematically tried to manipulate climate-change science and minimize the dangers of global warming, asserts a U.S. congressional report prepared by Democrats after a 16-month investigation. Republicans called it a "partisan diatribe" against the Bush administration.

The report issued Dec. 10 by Rep. Henry Waxman, a Democrat, relies on hundreds of internal communications and documents and testimony at two congressional hearings to outline a pattern where scientists and government reports were edited, according to Waxman, to emphasis the uncertainties surrounding global warming.

Many of the allegations of interference dating back to 2002 have surfaced previously, although the report by the Democratic majority of the House Oversight and Reform Committee sought to show a pattern of conduct.

"The Bush administration has engaged in a systematic effort to manipulate climate change science and mislead policymakers and the public about the dangers of global warming," concludes the report.

It said the White House over the years has sought to control public access to government climate scientists, suppressed scientific views that conflicted with administration policy and extensively edited government reports "to minimize the significance of climate change."

The White House called the findings "rehash and recycled rhetoric" that has been addressed by administration officials in the past. "It's a thinly veiled attempt to distract attention from the administration's efforts ... at the Bali summit," said White House spokeswoman Emily Lawrimore.

The report was issued as government officials from across the globe were meeting in Bali, Indonesia, to map out a strategy for dealing with climate change after 2012 when the Kyoto Protocol on climate expires. The United States is a participant.

Rep. Tom Davis, the ranking Republican on the House committee, issued his own report disputing the Democrats' conclusions.

The Democrats "grossly exaggerated" claims of political interference and ignored "the legitimate role of policymakers, instead of scientists, in making administration policy." said the GOP rebuttal. It said requests to the media about science were referred to scientists.

Among the findings cited by the Democrats were:

  • The White House Council on Environmental Quality made 294 edits to the administration's 2003 strategic plan for its climate-change science program. It said the changes were to either emphasize uncertainties or diminish the importance of the human role in global warming.
  • Media requests for interviews with climate scientists were routinely routed through the CEQ which often sought to make available scientists whose views were more aligned with administration policy.
  • Climate scientists' testimony before Congress was often heavily edited by political appointees. In cases cited in the report scientists were persuaded to play down the human influence on climate change and — in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina — the link between climate change and hurricanes.

James Connaugton, the CEQ chairman, rejected suggestions that science was being ignored or suppressed.

"This administration has an unparalleled record of supporting funding, advancing and publicizing climate change research," said Connaughton in a statement. "Claims that this administration interfered with scientists and with the science are false."

He said that nearly $12 billion has been devoted to advance climate-change science since 2001 and that peer-reviewed findings by U.S. government scientists have been a prominent part of assessments issued by the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the group of international scientists spearheading research into global warming.

Ex-EPA official: Cheney's office urged cuts in climate testimony
Sen. Barbara Boxer said heavy editing of CDC presentation to Congress was part of effort aimed at 'covering up the real dangers of global warming and hiding the facts from the public.' 07.09.08

Scientists claim White House controlled climate message
Senate, House hold hearings into whether Bush administration 'suppressed and manipulated' data on global warming. 02.01.07


Smithsonian accused of watering down climate-change exhibit

Former administrator says museum officials toned down Arctic exhibit for fear of angering Congress, Bush administration. 05.23.07

Surgeon general says Bush officials muzzled him

Dr. Richard Carmona tells Congress that his speeches were edited by political appointees, he was told not to talk about certain issues including sex education. 07.11.07

Federal judge: White House must release global-warming reports
Court agrees with environmentalists, finding administration violated 1990 law when it failed to meet deadlines for producing documents. 08.23.07

Conservationists sue for data on endangered species
Center for Biological Diversity seeks documents about Interior Department decisions group claims were tainted by political pressure. 12.31.07

Conservationists sue for documents on Chukchi Sea oil-lease sale
Groups claim federal government hasn't disclosed records that could show harmful effects to polar bears, other Arctic marine animals. 01.29.08

Congressman pushes EPA for records on Calif. waiver denial
Henry Waxman says he'll subpoena documents involving White House, Justice Department if agency doesn't set 'acceptable' schedule for release. 03.11.08

Scientist says CDC bosses ignored pleas about FEMA trailers
Toxicologist Christopher De Rosa tells congressional panel that he was told not to write e-mails about his concerns. 04.03.08

EPA scientists complain about political pressure
More than half of nearly 1,600 respondents in survey released by advocacy group say they have been pushed by superiors to skew their findings. 04.26.08

Democrats say politics at work in decisions on toxic chemicals
'By placing politics before science, the Bush administration is putting the public in harm's way,' says Sen. Barbara Boxer at committee hearing on EPA programs. 04.30.08

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

Last system update: Tuesday, February 9, 2010 | 04:52:54
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links