First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
print this   Print

Idaho man files $1 million legal claim over libel arrest

By The Associated Press

OSBURN, Idaho — A man arrested after he put signs in his yard and on his car because he said he wanted to make neighbors aware of sex offenders has filed a legal claim against this northern Idaho city, its police department and its police chief.

L.D. Bryson is asking for $1 million for what he said was a violation of his First Amendment rights, harassment and intimidation, emotional distress and attorney fees.

"They threatened my mom and dad if we didn't take the signs down," said Bryson, now living in nearby Kellogg and not allowed to return to the house in Osburn by court order.

Osburn Police Chief Spike Angle told the Associated Press yesterday that he could not comment on the claim filed on Dec. 22. Filing a claim is the initial process in bringing a lawsuit against a government entity.

Bryson was arrested in August and charged with libel after he placed eight signs in the yard of the home he shared with his parents in Osburn that read: "Do you have a level 3 neighbor?" and "Are your kids safe?" He spent one day in jail, and Bryson said officials told him he could face a $300 fine and six months in jail per sign.

In Idaho, libel is a criminal offense punishable by a fine up to $5,000 or imprisonment up to six months.

Bryson said he put up the signs after abduction and sexual-assault victim Shasta Groene was found with convicted sex offender Joseph Edward Duncan III. Duncan is accused of breaking into the Coeur d'Alene-area home shared by Mark McKenzie and Brenda Groene and three of her children on May 16, 2005. McKenzie, Brenda Groene and 13-year-old Slade Groene were bound and bludgeoned to death.

Authorities contend Duncan killed the couple so he could kidnap 8-year-old Shasta and her 9-year-old brother Dylan for sex. Dylan Groene's remains were found shortly after Duncan was arrested.

Some of Bryson's neighbors said they felt the signs were offensive and gave the impression that someone in the neighborhood was a sex offender. Bryson said one neighbor said that the signs made Bryson guilty of libel. Bryson said he did not intend to call attention to anyone in the neighborhood.

"The people next door don't want to believe that the signs have nothing to do with them," Bryson said. "I was making a political statement."

Bryson said it was his right to post signs on private property. He said he also put signs on his vehicle, and then moved the car to private property when police officers told him to remove the signs because the vehicle was parked on county property.

"Nothing is done to protect the children," he said. "I lived less than 100 yards away from Interstate 90. There are so many kids in that neighborhood."


Utah high court tosses criminal-libel law

Statute had been used to arrest, charge teen for making disparaging comments about school officials, classmates on his personal Web site. 11.18.02

Kan. man fined for anti-war signs in his yard

Prairie Village resident appeals ticket, arguing that ordinance restricts political speech. 12.28.05

Judge dismisses lawsuit stemming from criminal-libel charge
Newspaper columnist, city councilman had accused Baxter Springs, Kan., officials of violating their civil rights by pursuing defamation charges. 12.29.05

Jailed for speech: Criminal libel is an old — and bad — idea
By Ken Paulson Poking fun at Colorado prof by doctoring his photo to look like KISS member is pure satire — it doesn't warrant confiscation of The Howling Pig newsletter publisher's computer. 01.18.04

The crime of speaking ill of your betters
By Paul K. McMasters Criminal-libel laws force defendants to face not individuals allegedly defamed, but the government as prosecutor and the taxpayer as underwriter. 11.06.05

Political yard signs

Libel & defamation

Criminal Libel

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

Last system update: Friday, April 23, 2010 | 15:58:06
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links