First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
 
print this   Print         E-mail this article  E-mail this article

Students lose Confederate-flag purse case in 5th Circuit

By David L. Hudson Jr.
First Amendment scholar
10.16.09

Texas public high school officials did not violate the First Amendment by prohibiting two female students from carrying purses featuring images of the Confederate flag to school, a federal appeals court panel has ruled.

The school district in Burleson has a policy barring students from wearing clothing or accessories that display “inappropriate symbolism, especially that which discriminates against other students based on race, religion or sex.” Burleson High School supplemented this districtwide regulation during the 2002-03 school year with a policy prohibiting the visible display of the Confederate flag on campus.

The high school adopted the policy after several incidents of racial tension and hostility at the school. In the 2002-03 school year 35 incidents of race-related problems were reported. One incident involved a Burleson High School student’s shoving a Confederate flag in the face of several members of an all-black volleyball team from a visiting school.

The two girls at Burleson High School — known in court papers as A.M. and A.T. — challenged the constitutionality of the policy after being told they could not carry their Confederate-flag purses on school grounds in January 2006. The students contended that the policy violated their free-expression rights. They also alleged that school officials committed viewpoint discrimination by singling out the Confederate flag for unfavorable treatment, while allowing students to wear other racially tinged clothing, such as Malcolm X and Mexican-nationalist T-shirts.

The girls sued in February 2007 in federal district court, which ruled in favor the school defendants. The district court found that school officials reasonably concluded that displaying the Confederate flag would cause substantial disruptions at school within the meaning of the U.S. Supreme Court’s seminal student-speech decision in Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District (1969).

In Tinker, the Court ruled that school officials in Iowa violated the First Amendment rights of several students when they enforced a ban on black armbands students had worn in part to protest U.S. involvement in Vietnam. Tinker established a standard — that school officials can punish student expression only if they can reasonably forecast that such student expression will cause a substantial disruption or material interference with school activities.

On appeal, a three-judge panel of the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals unanimously affirmed the lower court Oct. 9 in A.M. v. Cash. The panel concluded that the lower court had applied the Tinker standard correctly.

“Applying the Tinker standard to the instant case, defendants reasonably anticipated that visible displays of the Confederate flag would cause substantial disruption of or material interference with school activities,” the court wrote. “There is ample, uncontroverted evidence that elements of the BHS student body have continually manifested racial hostility and tension.”

The plaintiffs argued that the school officials had to show more than simply generalized racial tension, but also a direct connection between the flag and disruptive activities.

The panel disagreed, writing: “But Tinker does not require a showing of past disruption; administrators can also meet their burden by establishing that they had a reasonable expectation, grounded in fact, that the proscribed speech would probably result in disruption.”

Kirk Lyons, attorney for the students, wrote in an e-mail to the First Amendment Center Online: "The court’s standard is so broad it negates Tinker. Any school can ban the Confederate flag (or symbol of choice) with impunity under such a standard. It has been a consistent problem with student free speech advocates in getting courts to hold schools to the burden set by Tinker."


Related

Tenn. Confederate-flag controversy set for Aug. trial

By David L. Hudson Jr. Former student contends he was improperly suspended for wearing T-shirt, belt buckle bearing the controversial symbol. 07.11.08

8th Circuit sides with Mo. school in dispute over Confederate flag

By David L. Hudson Jr. Judges cite racial incidents in agreeing that Farmington High officials can prohibit rebel symbols. 02.02.09

Federal judge sides with S.C. district in Confederate-flag case

Attorney for former student challenging ban says dispute 'would be a good case to take to the Supreme Court.' 09.17.09

High court turns away students' challenge of Confederate-flag ban
Teens at Maryville, Tenn., high school were threatened with suspension if they wore T-shirts featuring Rebel emblem. 10.08.09

Clothing, dress codes & uniforms

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.



Last system update: Friday, April 23, 2010 | 16:00:18
 SEARCH  MORE
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
Video/RSS/podcasts
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment
reports

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
Columnists
Experts
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Glossary
Freedom Sings™
Events
First Amendment
Schools

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment
Library

Lesson plans
freedomforum.org
Newseum
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links