First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
print this   Print

White supremacist's Web posts weren't threats

By The Associated Press

CHICAGO — A federal judge has dismissed a charge that an avowed white supremacist used his Web site to encourage harm to a juror, saying that the postings were protected by the constitutional right to freedom of speech.

William White of Roanoke, Va., the self-styled leader of the American National Socialist Workers Party, published the name, photograph, home address and phone number of the juror on his Web site, The juror had been a foreman of a jury that in April 2004 convicted another avowed white supremacist, Matthew Hale, of soliciting the murder of a federal judge.

Judge Lynn Adelman said in his July 21 ruling in U.S. v. White that the postings stopped short of specifically urging anyone to harm the juror.

"The fact that defendant knew that white supremacists sometimes viewed his Web site and sometimes harmed people they perceived as enemies is insufficient to transform his lawful statements about Juror A into criminal advocacy," Adelman wrote.

"Knowledge or belief that one's speech, even speech advocating law breaking, may cause others to act, does not remove the speech from the protection of the First Amendment unless the speech is directed to inciting imminent lawless action and is likely to produce such action."

White's Web site regularly attacked non-whites, Jews and homosexuals and expressed approval of acts of violence. The foreman's name had not previously been public; the juror had been identified only as "Juror A" in court documents.

First Assistant U.S. Attorney Gary S. Shapiro said the government was reviewing the ruling and would consider what steps to take next if any.

White's attorney, Nishay Kumar Sanan, said Adelman "obviously followed the law and made the right decision — that Bill White's speech was protected by the First Amendment." He said the government already had sought to stay the ruling while it decides whether to appeal.

White also faces federal charges in Virginia of making online threats to several other people, including a civil rights lawyer in Canada and a mayor in New Jersey. Even if the government does not appeal, White cannot be released until there is a bond hearing in the Virginia case, Sanan said.

Adelman, whose court is in Milwaukee, was brought into the case after Chief Judge James F. Holderman recused all of the judges of the Chicago-based U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois from sitting in the case. He acted because the Hale case involved a Chicago-based judge.


White supremacist charged with seeking to kill judge in trademark case

'Freedom of speech does not include the freedom to solicit murder,' prosecutor says concerning case of Matt Hale. 01.09.03

FBI steps up monitoring of hate groups' Web sites

After conviction of white supremacist Matthew Hale for trying to have judge murdered, government says it won't tolerate anyone crossing line from protected speech to advocating violence. 04.28.04

FBI report labels activist groups potential terrorists
Anti-war groups, animal rights activists, affirmative action organizations among those mentioned in document released to ACLU in response to FOIA lawsuit. 08.30.05

Military high court: soldier's racist speech not criminal
Jeremy Wilcox's white-supremacist statements didn't go far enough to justify criminal charges, justices rule. 07.18.08

Federal court allows white supremacist's trial to proceed
Defense attorneys had asked judge to dismiss charges, arguing that William A. White's e-mails, online postings were protected by First Amendment. 12.03.09

Federal jury: White supremacist guilty of making online threats
Attorneys for William A. White had argued that e-mails, postings were protected speech. 12.21.09

True threats

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

Last system update: Friday, April 23, 2010 | 16:03:58
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links