First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
print this   Print

Audit: Agencies lag in following Obama's openness order

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON — President Barack Obama is having difficulty getting all federal agencies to follow his order to deliver “a new era of open government,” according to a study of how they administer the Freedom of Information Act.

The National Security Archive, a private group that publishes declassified government information and uses the act and lawsuits to pry out official records, found a decidedly mixed record in an audit of how 90 agencies responded to Obama directives to open more records, and the guidelines and training sessions that followed from the Justice Department.

Rescinding a Bush policy of defending any legal reason to withhold information, Obama ordered agencies to release any information whose disclosure wasn’t prohibited by law or wouldn’t cause foreseeable harm.

The audit was released yesterday, the first day of Sunshine Week, an annual observance by journalism and other organizations to promote open government and freedom of information.

The Obama administration “has clearly stated a new policy direction for open government but has not conquered the challenge of communicating and enforcing that message throughout the executive branch,” the report concluded.

Among the findings the archive found most troubling were:

  • Ancient requests still linger, and 33 of the 90 agencies now have an older unfulfilled request than they did on Sept. 30, 2008.

  • Five agencies reported releasing less and withholding more information during the 2009 budget year, which includes the first nine months of the Obama administration, than they did the previous year.

  • 35 of the 90 agencies told the auditors they had no records of putting in place the new Obama FOIA policies.

    Norm Eisen, White House special counsel for ethics and government reform, responded that the Obama administration had spent the year building “the infrastructure to create a lasting change.” He said government data to be released this week would show positive trends, including “that there were more full and partial FOIA releases, although we agree it’s too soon for a final judgment.”

    The oldest pending request the auditors found is approaching 18 years old. It was submitted Sept. 21, 1992, by the National Security Archive itself to the National Archives and Records Administration for files on nuclear arms control and test information from 1959 to 1961. The audit said the request is probably languishing at the Energy Department and the Air Force because the National Archives must refer requests to the agencies where the information originated.

    On a positive note, the audit found that 20 of the 90 agencies had improved the date of their oldest open request from 2008 by more than one month, and the CIA improved its oldest request by nearly a year and a half.

    The auditors also found that four agencies — the departments of Justice and Agriculture, the Office of Management and Budget and the Small Business Administration — had both increased the number of requests that got all or part of the documents sought and decreased the number that were completely denied, compared with 2008.

    But the departments of State, Transportation and the Treasury, along with NASA and the National Reconnaissance Office, granted full or partial releases to fewer requests and completely denied more requests than the year before.

    The auditors found 13 of the 90 agencies could document concrete changes to their FOIA practices as a result of Obama’s policy, and another 14 had enhanced their training about Obama’s presumption of disclosure.


    Audit finds Bush order barely trims FOIA backlog

    'Behind its ambitious facade, the order lacked both carrot and stick,' states National Security Archive report. 03.21.08

    Obama orders rollback of government secrecy

    On first full day of office, new president moves to open presidential records, change how agencies interpret freedom-of-information law, limit lobbying. 01.22.09

    FBI finds no records for 2 out of 3 requesters, group says
    National Security Archive, which says agency is using outdated and deliberately limited search process, gives bureau its Rosemary Award for worst FOIA performance by federal agency. 03.13.09

    AP chief: Obama's transparency message hasn't 'reached the street'
    Senate holds hearing to review work by new office charged with reviewing compliance with open-government laws, mediating disputes with public. 09.30.09

    Sunshine Week 2010 at a glance
    A look at this year's Sunshine Week activities. 03.14.10

    Obama deputy: Transparency a priority, but takes time
    By Gene Policinski Training is an issue, Norman Eisen says at National FOI Day.
  • Madison Award 03.15.10

    AP review: Use of FOIA exemptions rose in 2009
    Study of reports filed by 17 federal agencies finds that despite president's promise of more openness, use of legal exemptions to keep records secret increased during last fiscal year. 03.16.10

    Will federal government become more open? Jury still out
    By Gene Policinski New plans for releasing more agency information — if carried out — will go a long way toward improving lukewarm rating President Obama has gotten from freedom of information advocates. 12.13.09

    National FOI Day

    News summary page
    View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

    Last system update: Friday, April 23, 2010 | 18:01:39
    About this site
    About the First Amendment
    About the First Amendment Center
    How to contribute
    First Amendment programs
    State of the First Amendment

    Religious liberty in public schools
    First Reports
    Supreme Court
    First Amendment publications
    First Amendment Center history
    Freedom Sings™
    First Amendment

    Congressional Research Service reports
    Guest editorials
    FOI material
    The First Amendment

    Lesson plans
    Contact us
    Privacy statement
    Related links