First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
print this   Print

FCC wants to reconsider indecency ruling

By The Associated Press

NEW YORK — The Federal Communications Commission rushed to judgment in concluding that “NYPD Blue” and three other television programs violated rules governing the broadcast of indecent and profane material, an FCC lawyer said yesterday.

The lawyer, Eric D. Miller, asked an appeals court to delay hearing a challenge to the FCC’s findings for two months so its board could hear the opinions of the owners of the programs and reconsider its rulings, which carried no fines.

In court papers, the FCC said it skipped its usual process of soliciting responses from the broadcasters because it believed the orders responded to requests from broadcasters for guidance on what violates the FCC’s new indecency and profanity rules.

The FCC said it acted faster than usual and did not propose fines for any of the programs, concluding only that the programs “apparently” violated the statutory and regulatory prohibitions on indecency and profanity.

Lawyers for several broadcasting companies told the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals they ultimately want to challenge the rules, which they say have infringed upon their First Amendment rights, exposing them to hefty fines for accidental broadcasts of isolated and fleeting expletives.

ABC Television Network, NBC Universal Inc., CBS Broadcasting Inc., Fox and their network affiliate associations challenged a March 15 FCC order resolving indecency complaints based on television programs that aired between February 2002 and 2004.

The broadcasters said federal indecency rules have been enforced inconsistently since the FCC in 2004 ruled that virtually any use of certain expletives would be considered profane and indecent. Millions of dollars in fines have been levied based on those rules.

The appeals challenged the FCC’s finding that profane language was used during the CBS program “The Early Show” in 2004, incidents involving Cher and Nicole Richie on the “Billboard Music Awards” shows broadcast by Fox in 2002 and 2003, and various episodes of the ABC show “NYPD Blue” that aired in 2003.

The FCC said it did not issue fines in those cases because the incidents occurred before the 2004 ruling.

While none of the cases involved NBC, the network filed a petition to intervene on behalf of the other networks and stations.

In an interview, attorney Carter G. Phillips, speaking on behalf of Fox Television Stations Inc., said the aim of the broadcasting companies was to have the appeals court declare that the March 15 orders regarding the four programs were unconstitutional.

He said the broadcasters want the FCC to return to the enforcement system that did not penalize accidental expletives.

In court papers, Phillips wrote that Fox’s principal concern is that a word that triggers an FCC fine, such as one uttered during a baseball game by an unhappy player or manager, might be inadvertently broadcast.

“The prospect of such massive fines obviously forces Fox to steer far clear of even constitutionally protected speech,” he wrote.

The appeals court reserved decision on whether to let the FCC take the case back.

2nd Circuit halts enforcement of tougher FCC indecency rules
Court also grants commission's request for additional two months to review its finding that 'NYPD Blue,' three other TV shows violated indecency guidelines. 09.08.06

TV networks, stations challenge FCC indecency ruling
Broadcasters call federal enforcement of rules on profane language vague, inconsistent. 04.17.06


PBS chief calls indecency rules unclear, 'paralyzing'

Paula Kerger says FCC regulations, fines put public TV stations at risk, threaten to deprive viewers of important programs. 07.29.06

CBS asks 3rd Circuit to overturn Super Bowl fine

Network argues $550,000 penalty for Janet Jackson's 2004 breast-baring performance is 'unconstitutional, contrary to the Communications Act and FCC rules and generally arbitrary, capricious and contrary to law.' 07.31.06

Some stations hesitate to air 9/11 documentary
CBS affiliates wary of possible fines over firefighters' foul language as decency group vows to flood FCC with complaints. 09.05.06

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

Last system update: Friday, April 23, 2010 | 19:19:48
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links