First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
print this   Print

White House logs show early visits by medical-industry execs

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON — Administration officials began talking privately to major players in the health care industry within a few weeks of President Barack Obama's inauguration, a newly released list of White House visitors shows.

During his presidential campaign, Obama promised to hold lobbyists at arm's length and make his administration the most transparent ever.

Last night, the Obama administration released the list of visits by health care executives after a government watchdog group, Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, announced it had filed a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit seeking the White House visitor logs. Only names and dates were released, not the visitors' titles or employers.

So far, the Obama administration is following a Bush administration policy of refusing to release the logs, which are maintained by the Secret Service.

The list shows that Richard Umbdenstock, president of the American Hospital Association, was at the White House on Feb. 4 and has been back at least a half-dozen times since then, most recently May 22. Other industry executives making February visits included health insurance company chief executives Angela Braly of WellPoint Inc. and Jay Gellert of Health Net Inc.

Gellert, a $500 donor to Obama's presidential campaign, visited the White House on Feb. 10, twice in March and on May 11, while Braly visited on Feb. 13.

In recent weeks, the White House has announced agreements under which hospitals and the pharmaceutical industry promised cost savings in return for an expanded base of insured patients. The deals were struck in private meetings, drawing comparisons to Vice President Dick Cheney's secret talks with the energy industry as he helped President George W. Bush draft a national energy policy. Cheney's 2001 meetings were criticized by Democrats throughout the Bush years.

Obama was asked at a news conference last night about his administration's refusal to say who had been to the White House to discuss a national health care overhaul.

"On the list of health care executives who visited us, most of time you guys have been in there taking pictures," he told the assembled reporters, "so it hasn't been a secret. And my understanding is we just sent a letter out providing a full list of all the executives. But, frankly, these have mostly been at least photo sprays where you could see who was participating."

CREW said it was pleased that the White House had provided the list but that it didn't consider it a sufficient response to its Freedom of Information Act request for the visitor logs themselves. It plans to continue pressing for them.

"The actual visitor records likely would indicate with whom each official met, the administration official who requested clearance for the visitor, the time of the meeting, the duration of the meeting and, in some cases, the purpose of the meeting. In addition, no information was provided regarding any visits to the vice president's residence," CREW said in a written statement.

Gregory Craig, White House counsel, told CREW in a letter that the White House was continuing to review the group's open-records request, "as well as the White House's general policy governing the discretionary release of visitor records."

White House logs detail who met with aides on health-care overhaul
Administration turns over 575 visitor records to Associated Press; documents seem to show visitors weighted heavily toward those who want to overhaul system. 11.30.09


Federal judge rules against White House on visitor logs

Court says likelihood of harm to president's ability to perform constitutional duties isn't great enough to justify curtailing public-disclosure goals of FOIA. 01.12.09

Federal judge: Cheney has broad discretion over records

However, court rejects Bush administration's expansive view that vice president alone has right to decide what Presidential Records Act means for his office. 01.20.09

Obama orders rollback of government secrecy
On first full day of office, new president moves to open presidential records, change how agencies interpret freedom-of-information law, limit lobbying. 01.22.09

Lawsuit accuses Obama White House of withholding visitor logs
Homeland Security Department tells watchdog group that records are governed by Presidential Records Act and not subject to disclosure under FOIA. 06.17.09

Obama: White House will release visitor logs
Policy set to begin Sept. 15; watchdog group applauds change, settles four pending Freedom of Information Act cases. 09.04.09

Public access to presidential records
By Gordon T. Belt A research article looking at the history, including recent controversies, of White House records. 02.20.09

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

Last system update: Friday, April 23, 2010 | 19:12:37
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Singsā„¢
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links