First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
print this   Print         E-mail this article  E-mail this article

Federal judge: Student had right to wear Confederate clothing

By David L. Hudson Jr.
First Amendment Center research attorney

A West Virginia high school student had a First Amendment right to wear Confederate flag clothing to school, a federal judge recently ruled.

Noting a “sea of interpretations about what the flag represents,” the judge reasoned that “there are a variety of innocent flag uses that would be silenced by the broadly worded policy” of Putnam County's Hurricane High School.

Franklin Bragg sued school officials after he was punished for wearing a “Dixie Outfitters” T-shirt and a belt buckle, both of which bore the flag’s image. School policy prohibited “racist language and/or symbols or graphics,” specifically including “the Rebel flag, which has been used as a symbol of racism at high schools in Putnam County.”

Bragg enlisted the help of the American Civil Liberties Union of West Virginia, which filed a federal lawsuit on his behalf in April 2005. On May 31, U.S. District Judge John T. Copenhaver Jr. ruled in a memorandum opinion and order in Bragg v. Swanson that Principal Joyce Vessey Swanson had violated Bragg’s First Amendment rights.

Swanson instituted the ban because she said she had had several negative experiences with the flag at other schools in the county. However, Copenhaver ruled Swanson had not shown much evidence of racial tension associated with the flag.

Copenhaver reasoned that the applicable legal standard for resolution of the case was Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School Dist., the U.S. Supreme Court’s 1969 decision upholding the right of several students to wear black armbands to school protesting U.S. involvement in Vietnam. The Court established the so-called Tinker standard, which holds that school officials can censor student expression if they can reasonably forecast that the expression will create a substantial disruption or material interference with school activities or will invade the rights of others. The Court in Tinker warned that school officials could not censor student expression based on “undifferentiated fear or apprehension of disturbance.”

Some courts have given school officials greater leeway to regulate the Confederate flag under a standard from the Supreme Court’s 1986 decision Bethel School District No. 403 v. Fraser, which established that school officials can prohibit student expression that is “vulgar, lewd or plainly offensive.”

However, Copenhaver refused to apply the Fraser standard, writing that “the display of the flag is not per se and patently offensive.”

Applying Tinker, Copenhaver said the principal did not have enough evidence to reasonably forecast that the flag would create a substantial disruption of school activities. Copenhaver said “the principal acted with ‘a remote apprehension of disturbance’ rather than a ‘specific and significant fear of disruption.’”

“Although the best of intentions undergird the policy, the offending portion unjustifiably silenced a significant amount of permissible speech in contravention of the First Amendment,” Copenhaver wrote.

He credited the testimony of Bragg’s friend, Lisa Adkins, an African-American student who said Bragg’s clothing did not bother her or other African-American students at Hurricane. The judge wrote that Adkins’ testimony showed that “there exists at the school an environment in which people of both races mix freely together and form good relationships.”

The judge also said it was problematic that school officials singled out the Confederate flag but allowed students to wear Malcolm X T-shirts.

However, he cautioned that his ruling in Bragg’s favor should not give anyone license to intimidate others with Confederate flag clothing: “This opinion should not be interpreted as offering a safe haven for those bent on using the flag in school as a tool for disruption, intimidation, or trampling upon the rights of others. Should that occur, or be reasonably forecast by the school, the very ban struck down today might be entirely appropriate.”

The West Virginia ACLU applauded the judge’s ruling. “The court recognized that allowing some expressions of political speech by students while banning others is a flagrant violation of the First Amendment,” said Executive Director Andrew Schneider in a news release. “We hope that the school will use this as an opportunity to teach students about their constitutional rights and encourage debate over future controversial subjects before resorting to censorship.”

Charleston, W.Va.-based attorney Greg Bailey, who represented the school board and the principal, said: “No decision has been made on whether to appeal. It is still under consideration. The superintendent plans to discuss it with the school board in the near future to decide what action to take.”


Teen barred from prom for Confederate-flag dress sues

Jacqueline Duty claims eastern Kentucky school district violated her free-speech rights. 12.21.04

Tennessee school board bans Confederate flag from sports events

Lone dissenting Maryville board member says policy — which bars all flags, signs, noisemakers, other objects from 'Red Rebels' home games — can't be enforced. 08.18.05

Clashes prompt Indiana high school to ban Confederate flag

'The Supreme Court has made it perfectly clear that if continued disruption occurs, we are compelled to act,' says Bloomington South principal. 11.01.05

Ky. high school, ex-student settle suit over Confederate-flag dress
Administrators had barred Jacqueline Duty from 2004 prom, saying dress was too controversial. 03.01.06

Student sues S.C. school over Confederate clothing
Candice Hardwick says she's honoring her heritage; school district says Rebel symbols racially charged, disruptive. 04.02.06

Mo. teen wants to show his 'Rebel Pride' at school
14-year-old hires First Amendment attorney, saying he won't return to school unless he can wear Confederate battle flag. 10.20.06

8th Circuit sides with Mo. school in dispute over Confederate flag
By David L. Hudson Jr. Judges cite racial incidents in agreeing that Farmington High officials can prohibit rebel symbols. 02.02.09

Confederate flags in public schools: Teach the controversy
By Charles C. Haynes Though rebel symbol can legally be barred from school in certain circumstances, it's better to engage the issues behind the dispute. 06.06.04

The Silencing of Student Voices

Clothing, dress codes & uniforms

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

Last system update: Friday, April 23, 2010 | 20:24:10
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links