First Amendment topicsAbout the First Amendment
News Story
print this   Print

Judge allows New York graffiti block party

By The Associated Press

NEW YORK — A federal judge yesterday ordered the city to allow an exhibition later this week in which 20 artists plan to spray-paint graffiti on models of subway cars.

The city, citing its years of work to clean up subways once plagued by graffiti, had argued the block party would encourage people to vandalize real subway cars.

But Judge Jed Rakoff of Manhattan federal court said the city's denial of a permit for the party was a "flagrant violation" of the First Amendment's free-speech protection.

Under the logic of Mayor Michael Bloomberg, the judge said in a brief order, "A street performance of 'Hamlet' would be tantamount to encouraging revenge murder."

The exhibition, set for tomorrow in the Chelsea district of Manhattan, is the brainchild of Marc Ecko, a fashion designer who began his career as a graffiti artist in New York.

According to plans laid out by Ecko's company, Ecko Unlimited, 20 former graffiti artists will spray graffiti onto two-dimensional replicas of subway cars.

The city initially granted a permit for the event, then said it was too commercial — original plans called for promotion of an Ecko video game — and ultimately revoked the permit on grounds that it would encourage a crime.

City lawyer Paula Van Meter had told the judge that young people could get the message that graffiti vandalism was acceptable and could easily repeat the act "down the street and down the stairs" in the subway system.

"It will raise to the consciousness once again, in a celebratory way, graffiti vandalism on subway cars," she said.

The judge noted that anyone who vandalized public property could be prosecuted. In his order, he quoted Bloomberg, who on his radio program on Aug. 19 said the exhibition was "trying to encourage people to do something that's not in anybody's interest."

The judge responded: "Such heavy-handed censorship would, moreover, fall particularly hard on artists, who frequently revel in breaking conventions or tweaking the powers that be."

Ecko, who sat before the judge with his lawyers yesterday, said after the ruling he was "just excited."

"We knew this was worth fighting for, and clearly the mayor must have been misinformed," he said.

Ecko Unlimited has said it arranged for a private security firm for the event and planned to post signs explaining that it's illegal to deface public places with graffiti.

Van Meter said after court that the city could still appeal.

Fashion designer to sue NYC mayor for canning graffiti party
Marc Ecko says Michael Bloomberg violated his free speech by revoking permit for event at which artists planned to spray-paint subway car replicas. 08.19.05


Graffiti artists tag NYC councilman as enemy No. 1

Peter Vallone, who calls graffiti vandalism, not art, wants tougher laws against the practice, including restrictions on some art supplies. 05.13.06

Appeals court blocks part of NYC anti-graffiti law

2nd Circuit finds that barring 18- to 21-year-olds from buying spray paint, markers had no 'rational basis.' 06.09.06

NYC can't block young adults from buying spray paint
2nd Circuit says portions of anti-graffiti law 'appear to burden substantially more speech than is necessary to achieve the city's legitimate interest in preventing illegal graffiti.' 02.02.07

Juvenile tagger can be barred from possessing graffiti tools
By David L. Hudson Jr. California appeals court rejects minor's free-expression argument, upholds parole condition. 09.18.09

News summary page
View the latest news stories throughout the First Amendment Center Online.

Last system update: Saturday, April 24, 2010 | 01:02:04
About this site
About the First Amendment
About the First Amendment Center
How to contribute
First Amendment programs
State of the First Amendment

Religious liberty in public schools
First Reports
Supreme Court
First Amendment publications
First Amendment Center history
Freedom Sings™
First Amendment

Congressional Research Service reports
Guest editorials
FOI material
The First Amendment

Lesson plans
Contact us
Privacy statement
Related links